The Academy: A Novel (The Academy Series, 1)

From #1 bestselling author of The Perfect Couple, Elin Hilderbrand, and her daughter, Shelby Cunningham, deliver the irresistible, deliciously scandalous story of one drama-filled year at a New England boarding school. It's move-in day at Tiffin Academy and amidst the happy chaos of friends reuniting, selfies uploading, and cars unloading, shocking news arrives: America Today just ranked Tiffin the number two boarding school in the country. It's a seventeen-spot jump--was there a typo? The dorms need to be renovated, their sports teams always come in last place, and let's just say Tiffin students are known for being more social than academic. On the other hand, the campus is exquisite, class sizes are small, and the dining hall is run by an acclaimed New York chef. And they do have fun--lots of parties and school dances, and a piano man plays in the student lounge every Monday night. But just as the rarefied air of Tiffin is suffused with self-congratulation, the wheels begin to turn--and then they fall off the bus. One by one, scandalous blind items begin to appear on phones across Tiffin's campus, thanks to a new app called ZipZap, and nobody is safe. From Davi Banerjee, international influencer and resident queen bee, to Simone Bergeron, the new and surprisingly young history teacher, to Charley Hicks, a transfer student who seems determined not to fit in, to Cordelia Spooner, Admissions Director with a somewhat idiosyncratic methodology--everyone has something to hide. As if high school wasn't dramatic enough ... As the year unfolds, bonds are forged and broken, secrets are shared and exposed, and the lives of Tiffin's students and staff are changed forever. The Academy is Elin Hilderbrand's fresh, buzzy take on boarding school life, and a thrilling new direction from one of America's most satisfying and popular storytellers.
BUY THE BOOK
Community Reviews
What Bookclubbers are saying about this book
✨ Summarized by Bookclubs AI
Readers say *The Academy* is a messy, mysterious, and addictive boarding school drama with sharp, modern storytelling, engaging multiple POVs, and lay...
I didn't expect to rate an Elin Hilderbrand* novel this poorly. Within the first 9 chapters The Academy takes on multiple (at least 17) important, heavy issues. This is a huge intake to absorb, paired with a large cast of characters introduced all at once and the result is overwhelming. The book is clumsy and stumbling; it's hard to know what it's about because it appears to be about everything, but only very shallowly. Which isn't interesting. As well, the characters are written as caricatures with zero depth while simultaneously normalizing underage sex/drinking/drug/porn use as if this a touchpoint for cultural relevancy. Stunning disappointment for a reader that enjoyed Golden Girl and The Five Star Weekend. This would have been a DNF if I hadn't been reading it for bookclub.
*Yes, I realize it's a collab. That's no excuse.
I picked this up after seeing the mother-daughter duo on GMA, and they absolutely delivered. If Gossip Girl went to a New England boarding school, got a group chat, and discovered TikTok, this would be the story that ensued. The Academy is messy, glossy, rumor-soaked fun, and I was locked in almost immediately. The rotating POVs work surprisingly well. Instead of feeling chaotic, it feels like you are piecing together secrets alongside a very online, and very nosy narrator.
The mystery of Cinnamon’s death hangs over the school like a storm cloud, even as Tiffin skyrockets in rankings and the board obsesses over money, donors, and reputation over actual learning. Meanwhile, relationships are forming, unraveling, and combusting. Rumors spread. Lines get crossed. Everyone has something to hide. I loved how the parents’ POVs added another layer of dysfunction, because wow, these adults are just as messy as the kids.
Audre was a standout for me. Calm, perceptive, quietly powerful, and absolutely the right person to clean house when things spiral. And while the Zip Zap reveal wasn’t shocking, I still enjoyed how everything wrapped up. Most loose ends were tied, the consequences mostly made sense, and I closed the book feeling satisfied instead of frustrated.
My one big gripe is that email attachment. You know the one. If that doesn’t come back as a major plot point in book two, I will be emailing the authors.
What really impressed me was how current this book feels without being cringe. The DraftKings references, the social media blind items, the Zip Zap app, all lands naturally. You can tell Shelby Cunningham’s influence is all over the voice of the students, and it keeps the story from slipping into “hello fellow kids” territory. This story truly feels like it’s happening right now.
This was fun, addictive, gossipy, and sharp. If you like boarding school drama, morally messy characters, and stories that feel like you’re scrolling a group chat you shouldn’t be in, put this on your list immediately. I will be seated for book two.
Tiffin Academy was mentioned in another Elin Hilderbrand Nantucket book, obviously to plug this series. Tiffin Academy is a fictional high school boarding school, located in remote western Massachusetts. The school gets a surprising second place ranking in the America Today poll of top-ranked boarding schools, jumping from #19, which draws suspicion among the other institutions and stimulates an official inquiry. During the academic year, we get to know the schoolteachers, counselors, head chef, security chief, headmistress, and of course, the students themselves. There’s an app called Zip Zap that puts out all sorts of juicy gossip on not only the kids, but on the staff. Things that are deeply personal and not shared with anyone. Then there’s the mystery of a student favorite, Cinnamon, who took her own life the previous year, and who, by all outward appearances seemed happy, well-adjusted and popular. Her best friend was Davi, a global style influencer, who in the aftermath is still dealing with her pain as she returns to school. There’s Dub, the school QB and Cinnamon’s boyfriend, who is there on academic scholarship from Durango, CO. And a new very studious student who has taken the place of the dead student. She knows more about the subject matter than some of the teachers. Another student was a rich kid named East, a 19 year old who was very smart but kept getting kicked out of schools because he wasn’t doing the work. His parents are too busy globe-hopping to pay him a visit. These students are equivalent juniors, and the next book will focus on them as they head into senior year. It took awhile to get into this book, a little overly-long when it didn’t need to be. But once the new student, Charley, gelled into the friend group, and the reader got to know the characters, the book became more engaging. The teaching staff and administrators were a head-scratching lot. There seemed to be no standards for hiring them, no background checks, which should have prevented their hire. So that didn’t seem very realistic. Now that I know the main characters, I’m looking forward to the next book in the series, ‘Thoroughbreds’ named after the school’s mascot.
The Academy by Erin Hilderbrand was, unfortunately, not for me. The book feels like a young-reader, toned-down version of Gossip Girl—so much so that Chuck Bass is name-checked directly, which only highlighted how unoriginal the premise felt.
I found the pacing slow, the plot predictable, and the characters flat. There was no emotional depth to pull me in, and I contemplated abandoning the book more times than I can count. Finishing it felt more like obligation than enjoyment.
The narration was another major struggle. The author jumps back and forth between 1st and 3rd person repeatedly, but not to give insight into a character’s perspective or enhance the storytelling. Instead, it reads like indecision on the page—disjointed, distracting, and lacking purpose.
What grated on me most was the tone of the writing itself. Throughout the book, Hilderbrand uses unnecessarily large, complex vocabulary, only to immediately turn around and define those same words for the reader. It came across less like helpful context and more like condescension—as if the prose was trying to sound intellectual, but the explanations assumed the reader wouldn’t understand it. The combination felt oddly patronizing and, at times, insulting to the audience’s intelligence.
I’ve enjoyed other books by Erin Hilderbrand, but this one missed the mark in nearly every way I value as a reader—originality, depth, and narrative cohesion.
Captivating and entertaining with a few slow moments
The Academy is another great addition to Elin Hilderbrand’s world of Nantucket storytelling — this time with a fun, mysterious boarding school twist. The characters are engaging and layered, and I loved how Hilderbrand blended drama, relationships, and suspense in such a vivid setting. The pacing was a little slow in the beginning, and a few subplots felt a bit rushed at the end, but overall it was a satisfying, addictive read that kept me guessing. Definitely a perfect book to curl up with on a cozy weekend!
The Academy is another great addition to Elin Hilderbrand’s world of Nantucket storytelling — this time with a fun, mysterious boarding school twist. The characters are engaging and layered, and I loved how Hilderbrand blended drama, relationships, and suspense in such a vivid setting. The pacing was a little slow in the beginning, and a few subplots felt a bit rushed at the end, but overall it was a satisfying, addictive read that kept me guessing. Definitely a perfect book to curl up with on a cozy weekend!