The Midnight Train: A Novel (The Midnight World)

A NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER
“Matt Haig returns with another life-affirming novel . . . If you enjoy the “Midnight” experience, climb aboard.” —The New York Times Book Review
When your life flashes before your eyes, where would you stop?
No one can change the past, but the Midnight Train can take you there.
The chance to re-live the moments that meant most.
To see what kind of person you really were.
For Wilbur his best days were with Maggie, the love of his life. On his honeymoon in Venice.
Before he gave it all away.
He wishes he could go back and live differently. But to do so risks everything . . .
A magical, time-travelling love story, from the world of The Midnight Library.
BUY THE BOOK
Join a book club that is reading The Midnight Train: A Novel (The Midnight World)!
Community Reviews
This one started off a little slow for me, but it picked up about halfway through. I really enjoyed it. I felt like there was a lot of reflection about how we live our life, the choices we make, and how it shapes who we become.
I should have re-read my review of the Midnight Library before choosing to listen to The Midnight Train. I could almost reprint everything I said other than the summary of the plot and it would apply here.
A man dies, boards a special train that allows (in some cases forces) the man to revisit meaningful moments in his life. There are rules. He can’t alter what he sees. He can’t be there when his former self goes to sleep. If he doesn’t obey the rules of this mandatory review, he doesn’t get to eternity. It’s meant to bring acknowledgement, acceptance and closure. But depending on your life, it could also bring regret. And asks the question, with the benefit of hindsight, what would you have done differently.
But what happens if someone doesn’t follow the rules? That’s what happens here. Because is it more important for him to reach eternity or give his still-alive-self the opportunity to change while there’s still time?
Think of this as A Christmas Carol for the modern age with Wilbur in the role of Ebenezer, but already with a sense of regret. It’s a sweet story, with an important message, but I didn’t feel it broke any new ground. It just felt way too predictable, obvious and simplistic. As I said in my review of TML, you don’t need a philosophy degree to know the point Haig is trying to make. Greed = bad. Love = good.
I listened to this and while I love James Norton as an actor, he was just ok as the narrator.
A man dies, boards a special train that allows (in some cases forces) the man to revisit meaningful moments in his life. There are rules. He can’t alter what he sees. He can’t be there when his former self goes to sleep. If he doesn’t obey the rules of this mandatory review, he doesn’t get to eternity. It’s meant to bring acknowledgement, acceptance and closure. But depending on your life, it could also bring regret. And asks the question, with the benefit of hindsight, what would you have done differently.
But what happens if someone doesn’t follow the rules? That’s what happens here. Because is it more important for him to reach eternity or give his still-alive-self the opportunity to change while there’s still time?
Think of this as A Christmas Carol for the modern age with Wilbur in the role of Ebenezer, but already with a sense of regret. It’s a sweet story, with an important message, but I didn’t feel it broke any new ground. It just felt way too predictable, obvious and simplistic. As I said in my review of TML, you don’t need a philosophy degree to know the point Haig is trying to make. Greed = bad. Love = good.
I listened to this and while I love James Norton as an actor, he was just ok as the narrator.
I didn't want to like this. I loved The Midnight Library so much that I was almost deliberately trying not to go into this with high expectations. I didn't want to compare it to that book or set myself up to be disappointed. But... yeah. I loved it.
There were definitely parts that got a little too fanciful for me, and a few things were difficult for me to fully grasp, but that didn't really matter. I was invested in the story and the characters, and I just loved it.
There were definitely parts that got a little too fanciful for me, and a few things were difficult for me to fully grasp, but that didn't really matter. I was invested in the story and the characters, and I just loved it.
This felt like someone took A Christmas Carol, removed the ghosts, the urgency, and most of the personality, then stretched it across an emotionally delayed train schedule.
The premise sounded incredible: a magical midnight train that lets you revisit the moments that shaped your life? Amazing. Existential. Potentially devastating in the best way. Instead, I got a slow-moving ride through regret with all the excitement of waiting at the DMV.
Wilbur spends the book reflecting on his past, his marriage, and the choices he made, except the execution felt like being trapped in a very long therapy session I didn’t agree to pay for.
I kept waiting for some emotional gut punch or mind-bending revelation, but the story just kind of politely wandered around the tracks.
There were moments where Matt Haig’s signature warmth and introspection peeked through, and I can absolutely see this working for readers who love quiet, reflective stories. Unfortunately, I needed more plot and less “sad man thinks about things for 300 pages.”
And listen, I love an emotional story. I voluntarily read books designed to emotionally ruin me for fun. But this one somehow managed to be both sentimental and painfully dull at the same time. That’s honestly kind of impressive.
Also, if you mention Venice enough times, I start expecting something dramatic to happen. A scandal. A murder. Someone falling into a canal. Anything.
In the end, this wasn’t a terrible book. It just felt like a very long inspirational quote riding public transportation.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Viking for this review copy.
The premise sounded incredible: a magical midnight train that lets you revisit the moments that shaped your life? Amazing. Existential. Potentially devastating in the best way. Instead, I got a slow-moving ride through regret with all the excitement of waiting at the DMV.
Wilbur spends the book reflecting on his past, his marriage, and the choices he made, except the execution felt like being trapped in a very long therapy session I didn’t agree to pay for.
I kept waiting for some emotional gut punch or mind-bending revelation, but the story just kind of politely wandered around the tracks.
There were moments where Matt Haig’s signature warmth and introspection peeked through, and I can absolutely see this working for readers who love quiet, reflective stories. Unfortunately, I needed more plot and less “sad man thinks about things for 300 pages.”
And listen, I love an emotional story. I voluntarily read books designed to emotionally ruin me for fun. But this one somehow managed to be both sentimental and painfully dull at the same time. That’s honestly kind of impressive.
Also, if you mention Venice enough times, I start expecting something dramatic to happen. A scandal. A murder. Someone falling into a canal. Anything.
In the end, this wasn’t a terrible book. It just felt like a very long inspirational quote riding public transportation.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Viking for this review copy.
A very interesting reflection of death and second chances. I like this take on life flashing before your eyes. It was thoughtful without being too heavy. Haig has been hit or miss with me since TML, but this was definitely a big hit. 4⭐️ Book #41 in 2026