Join a book club that is reading Priest: A steamy, forbidden romance of secrets and temptation (Priest, 1)!

Twisted Tomes Bookclub📍AZ

📍Phoenix, AZ Looking to start in person meetings twice a month. GenZ book club, 18+ (sorry🤷🏻‍♀️) Dark romance, Romantasy, Romance, YA

Priest: A steamy, forbidden romance of secrets and temptation (Priest, 1)

He vowed to serve God. But the moment she spoke, he wanted to worship her instead.

From USA Today and Wall Street Journal bestseller Sierra Simone comes a darkly poetic, emotionally charged taboo romance where every choice is a sin, and every touch feels like salvation.

When Father Tyler Bell hears Poppy Danforth's voice in his confessional, everything he believes begins to fracture. His vows. His purpose. His faith. What begins as a spiritual struggle becomes a sensual awakening that threatens to consume them both. Torn between salvation and desire, Tyler must choose which altar to kneel before: the church...or her.

Priest is a gripping journey into the heart of forbidden love, with achingly lyrical prose, explosive heat, and the kind of intimate, boundary-pushing passion that will leave you breathless.

BUY THE BOOK

Published Mar 15, 2022

320 pages

Average rating: 6.6

362 RATINGS

|

Community Reviews

Annie.S
May 07, 2025
9/10 stars
I loved that this book wove the feeling of religion and of love together so beautifully. Also it was hot so so hot!
Clara Fox
Jul 25, 2025
5/10 stars
I have mixed feelings about this book. First half: 🌶️ 🌶️ 🌶️ 🌶️ Second half: 🌶️ 🌶️ 🌶️ The good: - The s*x scenes are well written and definitely spicy. Lots of playing around with various taboos, as well as themes of domination/subjugation, and self-control. There were a couple really good scenes, which I felt were much better written then some other popular books in this genre. -S*x scenes are frequent, particularly in the first half. Lots of things happening inside the church itself, which I assume most people reading this genre want. - MMC is very likeable and relatively multi-faceted. He was well written, for this type of genre. I'd have him as a book boyfriend any day of the week. - There was an attempt at a plot (albeit, a predictable one) - Descriptions of religious items, themes, places, etc. were well-informed. You can tell the author did her research. - It's a shorter read so you don't have to take days and days to read through it (unless you would like to). The bad: - I hated the MFC. She initially comes across as a manipulative s*x addict, purposefully trying to tempt the priest away from the church. I got the sense she knew exactly what she was doing. Then half way through she becomes almost a completely different character. I assume this is the author's attempt at character development, but it falls flat imo. She gives so many mixed signals, makes completely selfish and/or irrational choices, does not communicate, is manipulative but in an "I'm a shitty person" kind of way, etc. She annoyed me, and I found myself less absorbed in the chapters with her POV because of how insufferable she is. - As a result of not liking the MFC, I didn't really like that they ended up together. I don't feel she was sufficiently redeemed. She remained annoying. - I recognize for the sake of plot, and probably as a result of this author's writing style, that a real, affectionate romance was going to blossom out of all the lust. It just seemed kind of forced and inauthentic. I didn't believe the MFC actually loved him, and I don't think the FMC had enough like... personality (? I don't really know) for him to completely F up his life for her. It felt weird that he was imploding his whole life's work/reputation/moral system for someone super mid tier. - The second half is less spicy, which I suppose is good if you like more plot driven stories. I felt it just started out BAM! and then fizzled out near the end (there are still spicy scenes, but imo they're less hot). Overall, worth a read if you're into the genre and this particular kink. I liked the audiobook. Most of my criticisms derive directly from me not liking the MFC, but maybe you'll find her less insufferable than I did.
Julia Gulia
Jun 05, 2025
9/10 stars
Very good- I’m just not a hopeless romantic.
Cindy Guinn
May 01, 2025
7/10 stars
This book made me blush. It was wild. 3.5⭐️
FabReads
Mar 29, 2025
6/10 stars
amen

Forgive us father for we have sinned. This is so sweetly sinful that I might need to go to church. But I love how the author intertwined guilt with redemption, lust with love, doubt with prayers. But I give it a 3, I feel like it was rushed and dragged at the same time. Character could use a little development. The break up was unnecessary, personally I think. Other than that I enjoyed the read.

See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.