What Have We Done: A Novel

In this “top-notch mystery thriller” (Publishers Weekly, starred review) from Alex Finlay, What Have We Done is a tale about the lives we leave behind and the secrets we carry with us forever.

One of the Most Anticipated Books of 2023:• BookPage • BookBub • E! News • Go BookMart • Goodreads • PopSugar The Every Girl • She Reads • Beyond the Bookends

A stay-at-home mom with a past.
A has-been rock star with a habit.
A reality TV producer with a debt.
Three disparate lives.
One deadly secret.

Twenty five years ago, Jenna, Donnie, and Nico were the best of friends, having forged a bond through the abuse and neglect they endured as residents of Savior House, a group home for parentless teens. When the home was shut down—after the disappearance of several kids—the three were split up.

Though the trauma of their childhood has never left them, each went on to live accomplished—if troubled—lives. They haven’t seen one another since they were teens but now are reunited for a single haunting reason: someone is trying to kill them.

To survive, the group will have to revisit the nightmares of their childhoods and confront their shared past—a past that holds the secret to why someone wants them dead.

It’s a reunion none of them asked for . . . or wanted. But it may be the only way to save all their lives.

What Have We Done is both an edge-of-your-seat thriller and a gut-wrenching coming-of-age story. And it cements Alex Finlay as one of the new leading voices in thrillers today.

BUY THE BOOK

Published Mar 7, 2023

432 pages

Average rating: 6.97

71 RATINGS

|

These clubs recently read this book...

The Grim Reader

Welcome to the Grim Readers Book Club! This book club is for those interested in horror, murder mystery, thriller, true crime, or anything else out of

Thrillers By The Book Club - ATX

We are a local in-person chapter of Thrillers by the Book Club in Austin, Texas. 

Community Reviews

What Bookclubbers are saying about this book

✨ Summarized by Bookclubs AI

Readers say *What Have We Done* is a gripping thriller weaving a complex past among foster kids now adults, with action and mystery that sustain suspe...

Andrea-The Shelf Life Books
Jul 03, 2025
8/10 stars
My Sincere thanks to Author, Alex Finlay, The Publisher, Minotaur Books, and NetGalley for the privilege of reading an advanced copy of What Have We Done.

This is another highly anticipated, riveting, capturing, action-packed, heart-throbbing Alex Finlay novel!

Four best friends from a group home haven't been in touch in 25 years. The stay-at-home mom, the has-been rockstar with an addiction problem, a powerful district judge, and the reality TV producer all share a secret. Three have survived recent assassination attempts of them.

What Have We Done is told from the alternating points of view of the three surviving members of Savior House. It’s mostly in the present but with occasional memories to relate moments from the past. The alternation of narrators does a nice job of slowly revealing little morsels about what happened, the characters’ various secrets, and the occasional red herring.

Now, these three have to come together, dodging the people who are out to assassinate them. If they don’t make it, the secret that they have been keeping for 25 years could come to the surface.

With rich characters and a lightning-fast plot, the mystery is compelling, and I didn’t see who was responsible until the very end. All the hype around this novel is well deserved!
Mary Pat Holt
Feb 05, 2026
2/10 stars
What have I just read? This was definitely not the thriller I was expecting. Someone is trying to kill former residents of Savior House, a group home for teens that was shut down 25 years ago after some kids and the director went missing. I was not a fan of this book. It started out ok and just got confusing and over the top ridiculous. The story is told through multiple POV's, present time and the past: Jenna is a pretty assassin turned yoga stepmom to 2 kids, Donnie is a washed up has been rocker and alcoholic, Nico is a reality TV show producer with a gambling problem. Artie, a tech billionaire who was a big nerd, and Ben, a smart guy who became a judge, were also young kids at Savior House (but story not told through their POV). Haley and Casey are psychopath twin sisters who did not live at SH and are modern day assassins.
jess.withbooks
Jun 05, 2025
4/10 stars
Neither the characters nor the plot inspired any motivation to continue reading this book…how I finished it is the true mystery here. A trip to Target would fill me with more suspense than any of the “plot twist” reveals.
Cindy Guinn
May 01, 2025
9/10 stars
4.5 ⭐️
Quick read that moved along quickly. Enjoyed to multiple pov. Audio was great.
MaggieParedes
Feb 10, 2025
6/10 stars
Thank you for this book in exchange for my honest review.

I had high hopes for this book due to the author’s previously written books that I’ve enjoyed. However, What Have We Done did not grip me like the other novels by Alex Finlay did. I found myself tuned out from the beginning.

See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.