'Twas the Night: A Novel – A Christmas Horror Mystery Where a Reporter Investigates Disappearances in a Village That Worships Santa

"A yuletide Midsommar drenched in eggnog and blood." -CLAY MCLEOD CHAPMAN, author of Wake Up and Open Your Eyes
A young reporter follows a string of disappearances into the middle of a terrifying Christmas cult inspired by our favorite holiday classics.
You better watch out. You better not cry.
It’s Christmas in the village of Yule, Maine.
In fact, it’s always Christmas in Yule. Here, Santa Claus isn’t a storybook figure. He’s an icon. A god. The villagers don’t just believe in him—they worship him. And the world is better for it.
Halley Belanger hates Christmas, and she doesn’t have much love for Santa either. But when a string of child disappearances across Maine seems to spare only the village of Yule, Halley—a sharp, skeptical reporter—decides to investigate.
What she finds is a town that guards its secrets with gingerbread smiles and a snow globe sheen. Outsiders aren’t welcome. She isn’t welcome. And something sinister is keeping the Christmas spirit alive.
As Halley digs deeper, she begins to uncover the horrifying truth behind Yule’s eternal cheer. Christmas comes at a grisly cost. And Santa Claus is no saint.
"The gleefully unhinged tale of holiday horror you've been waiting for." -ERIC LAROCCA, author of Things Have Gotten Worse Since We Last Spoke
BUY THE BOOK
Join a book club that is reading 'Twas the Night: A Novel – A Christmas Horror Mystery Where a Reporter Investigates Disappearances in a Village That Worships Santa!
Community Reviews
When children begin disappearing across Maine—except in the always-festive town of Yule—skeptical reporter Halley Belanger investigates. What she finds is a secretive village that worships Santa Claus and hides something far more sinister beneath its holiday cheer. As Halley gets closer to the truth, she discovers that Yule’s Christmas spirit comes at a deadly cost.
Told in the third person, the novel primarily follows Halley’s perspective as she sets out in search of—and ultimately discovers—the mysterious town of Yule. Seeking refuge from a blizzard, she takes shelter in an Inn that is not open to the public, though the question of whether her hosts can be trusted lingers.
The story leans into its eerie premise with striking imagery, including towering nutcrackers and an unsettling army of snowmen, creating a distinctly haunting atmosphere.
The author excels at building a vivid setting, immersing the reader in both the sinister charm of Yule and the unsettling reinterpretation of the North Pole. Character development is another strength; as the narrative progresses, the emotional investment in Halley and those around her grows, making their fates compelling to follow.
While the plot unfolds in a somewhat predictable manner, the journey itself remains engaging—the intrigue lies less in what happens and more in how events come together. The horror elements are handled with restraint for much of the book, with blood and gore largely confined to the final quarter, which may appeal to readers who prefer atmosphere over constant intensity.
One lingering question centers on the story’s underlying mythology. The contrast between Santa’s benevolent role in the wider world and his apparent cruelty toward this town and his “elves” feels underdeveloped and somewhat inconsistent, leaving a noticeable gap in the narrative’s internal logic.
Overall, this is a well-crafted and atmospheric horror novel with strong setting and character work, even if its plot follows familiar beats. I would rate it 3.5 out of 5 stars.
Thank you to HarperCollins Publishers and NetGalley for the advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.