The Society of Unknowable Objects: A Novel

From the author of the internationally bestselling The Book of Doors, another fantastical, stand-alone novel in which a trio of seemingly everyday people are members of a secret society tasked with finding and protecting hidden magical objects—ordinary items with extraordinary properties.
The world of unknowable objects—magical items that most people have no idea possess powers—has been quiet for decades, but the three current members of a secret society have remained watchful, meeting every six months in the basement of a bookshop in London. They are pledged to protect their archive of magical items hidden away, safe from the outside world—and the world safe from them. But when Frank Simpson, the longest-standing member of the Society of Unknowable Objects, hears of a new artifact coming to light in Hong Kong, he sends Magda Sparks—author by day and newest member—to investigate.
Within hours of arriving in Hong Kong, Magda is facing death and danger, confronted by a professional killer who seems to know all about unknowable objects, specifically one that was stolen from him a decade before. Magda is forced to flee, using an artifact that not even the rest of the Society knows about.
Returning to London, Magda learns hers is not the only secret being kept from the other two members. And that the most pernicious secret is about the nature of the Society’s mission. Her discoveries will lead her on a perilous journey, across the Atlantic to the deep south of the United States, now in pursuit of not an unknowable object, but an unknowable person: the professional killer she first faced in Hong Kong. In doing so, Magda begins to understand that there are even more in the world who are chasing these magical items, and that her own family’s legacy is tied up in keeping all these secrets under wraps.
Magic has always been too powerful to reveal to the world. But Magda will learn there might be something even more powerful:
The truth.
BUY THE BOOK
Community Reviews
First Impressions
After reading The Book of Doors, I was genuinely excited to return to Gareth Brown’s magical universe. I loved the sense of wonder in that first book, the idea that something as ordinary as a book could hold extraordinary power, and the possibilities that opened up because of it.
So when I picked up The Society of Unknowable Objects, I had pretty high expectations. Did it live up to them? Not entirely. But there were definitely parts of this story that reminded me why I was so interested in this world in the first place.
The Story
The novel follows a secret society dedicated to finding, collecting, and safeguarding objects with extraordinary abilities. These aren’t necessarily objects that look magical. They could be things you’d walk right past without giving them a second thought.
And that’s something I really love about Gareth Brown’s imagination. The idea that magic could exist quietly alongside our everyday lives is fascinating to me. But this isn’t just a story about discovering magical objects. It’s also about the people who possess them, the secrets they keep, and the decisions they make when they’re given access to something incredibly powerful.
There’s mystery, adventure, shifting timelines, and plenty of moral ambiguity along the way.
Where I Struggled
My biggest issue was the pacing. I really struggled through the first two parts of this book. There were stretches where I felt like I was waiting for something to happen that would finally pull me into the story.
The different timelines and storylines didn’t necessarily bother me in principle. I actually enjoy books that weave together multiple perspectives and gradually reveal how everything connects. But here, I sometimes felt like I was spending more time trying to figure out why certain events mattered than actually enjoying what was happening. And when things finally started coming together, I couldn’t help thinking that I wished we’d reached that point sooner.
Another issue was the character relationships. I never felt particularly connected to most of the characters, and that made it difficult to become emotionally invested in what happened to them. There were relationships that were clearly supposed to carry emotional weight, but I didn’t feel like we’d spent enough time seeing those connections develop.
It’s one thing to tell me two people are incredibly important to each other. It’s another thing entirely to make me feel it. For me, that emotional foundation was missing. And I think that’s especially disappointing in a story that seems to have elements of found family, because those relationships should be part of what makes the journey meaningful.
What Finally Caught My Attention
Now, there was one character who genuinely changed my level of interest in this book: Lukas.
I’m being deliberately careful here because I don’t want to spoil anything, but his character was easily one of the most intriguing parts of the entire story. The more I learned, the more questions I had.
I wanted to understand his history, his motivations, his loneliness, and what had shaped him into the person we encounter. What I found particularly interesting was that my feelings toward him weren’t straightforward. I could recognize troubling choices while still wanting to understand the person behind them. And that, to me, is where some of the most interesting storytelling happens.
Unfortunately, I also felt like there was so much more to explore with his character than what we were given. He was one of the reasons I finally became invested, and I genuinely wish we’d spent more time with him.
The Questions That Made Me Think
One thing I appreciated was how much this story made me question the responsibility that comes with power.
If an object has extraordinary abilities, does that automatically make it dangerous? Or does the danger come from the person using it? Who gets to decide which people should have access to magic? And at what point does protecting something become controlling it?
These were some of my favorite ideas to explore while reading. I also found myself questioning whether good intentions are enough to justify someone’s decisions. Because someone can genuinely believe they’re doing the right thing and still cause harm. That doesn’t necessarily make them evil, but it doesn’t automatically excuse the consequences either.
I wish the book had spent even more time exploring some of these questions, because I think there’s a tremendous amount of potential in them.
The Magic and the Missed Opportunities
I love the concept of magical objects having their own histories, abilities, and purposes. There are so many directions an author could take that idea, and I think Gareth Brown has created a world with enormous storytelling possibilities.
But I sometimes felt like we spent more time chasing objects than actually discovering what made them extraordinary. I wanted to understand their magic. I wanted to explore their histories. I wanted more of that sense of discovery that made The Book of Doors so memorable for me.
There were also storylines and character histories that felt like they deserved more attention. By the end, I had more unanswered questions than I expected, and not necessarily in the satisfying, mysterious way.
Some mysteries are wonderful to leave open. Others feel like missing pieces of a story I was trying to understand. For me, this book had a little too much of the latter.
My Final Thoughts
Despite everything I’ve criticized, I don’t think The Society of Unknowable Objects is a bad book. I think it’s a book with an incredibly interesting premise, some genuinely compelling ideas, and a magical world that still has so much potential. It just didn’t come together in the way I’d hoped.
The pacing made it difficult to get invested early on, the relationships didn’t have the emotional depth I wanted, and some of the most fascinating possibilities felt underexplored. But when the story finally caught my attention, I was reminded of why I enjoy Gareth Brown’s imagination so much.
And even though this particular journey left me somewhat disappointed, I’m still interested in seeing where this magical universe could go next.
Would I Recommend It?
Yes, particularly to readers who enjoy magical mysteries, secret societies, morally complicated characters, and stories that take their time revealing how everything connects.
But if you’re someone who needs strong emotional connections with characters or prefers a faster-moving fantasy, this one might require a little patience.
My final rating: 3.5/5 stars. An imaginative story with fascinating possibilities, but one that left me wishing we’d explored more of its magic, its characters, and the questions it raised.
I received this DRC from NetGalley.
I enjoyed The Book of Doors, and so I was excited to read this one. I liked the premise, and the book started off being interesting, but as the story progressed, it just didn't work. The villain through the first half was just a generic, non-nuanced bad guy, so reading his part was a bit rough. And then the characters just kept making infuriatingly dumb decisions only to prolong the story. There were a few points where the book could have been way shorter had the characters done the thing that was obviously the thing they should have done, making the writing just feel lazy. Ironically, at the end, one character lightly calls out another character by asking if there could have been a more creative solution that would have fixed everything with a better outcome. But of course, this is just brushed off as nothing, even though, yes, more creativity would have fixed a lot. Instead, we just have this girl who can't control her emotions or think logically, and we're expected to believe she's a good candidate to have control over magical items that could cause catastrophic harm? Literally, her only qualification is nepotism.
There were a few positives. I did like that it was set in the same world as Book of Doors. I prefer more subtlety, so I didn't really need the epilogue, but at least it was short. There were other reveals that I thought were pretty good, too, but they just didn't make up for the other stuff that I found lacking.
I really wanted this book to be better than it was.
I enjoyed The Book of Doors, and so I was excited to read this one. I liked the premise, and the book started off being interesting, but as the story progressed, it just didn't work. The villain through the first half was just a generic, non-nuanced bad guy, so reading his part was a bit rough. And then the characters just kept making infuriatingly dumb decisions only to prolong the story. There were a few points where the book could have been way shorter had the characters done the thing that was obviously the thing they should have done, making the writing just feel lazy. Ironically, at the end, one character lightly calls out another character by asking if there could have been a more creative solution that would have fixed everything with a better outcome. But of course, this is just brushed off as nothing, even though, yes, more creativity would have fixed a lot. Instead, we just have this girl who can't control her emotions or think logically, and we're expected to believe she's a good candidate to have control over magical items that could cause catastrophic harm? Literally, her only qualification is nepotism.
There were a few positives. I did like that it was set in the same world as Book of Doors. I prefer more subtlety, so I didn't really need the epilogue, but at least it was short. There were other reveals that I thought were pretty good, too, but they just didn't make up for the other stuff that I found lacking.
I really wanted this book to be better than it was.
This book was a fun escapist read, but it followed a very similar plot structure to Gareth Brown's other famous Book of Doors.
One of my favorites now. Wow, it moves like a bullet train