The September House

A woman is determined to stay in her dream home even after it becomes a haunted nightmare in this compulsively readable, twisty, and layered debut novel.

BUY THE BOOK

Published Sep 5, 2023

368 pages

Average rating: 7.34

477 RATINGS

|

These clubs recently read this book...

Bookalicious Babes of Austin

This book club is designed for Austin women who love to read and chat and drink wine. Most of our members are in their mid-20s to 30s. We meet once monthly to discuss a book of everyone's choosing and do additional meetups throughout each month that are not book-related, such as happy hours, hikes, and game nights. We’re excited to connect and look forward to discussing our latest read!

Boozy Horror Book Club

Do you wish it was Halloween year-round? Want to meet like minded folks and read some spooky books? Then this online book club is for you!

Versed Vixens

Versed Vixens is an enchanting book club that brings together a group of vibrant and passionate women who share a love for literature and the power of

Community Reviews

What Bookclubbers are saying about this book

✨ Summarized by Bookclubs AI

Readers say *The September House* by Carissa Orlando is a gripping, gothic horror novel blending eerie haunted house vibes with dark humor and emotion...

Kelley-Ernst
Sep 07, 2024
8/10 stars
This book was a little slower to build up momentum than I had expected, and in fact I almost put it down about a third of the way through. I’m so glad I didn’t, however, because from there things picked up with a vengeance! The ending is nothing short of awesome. This book really, really surprised me—overall it kind of has the feel of something like Burnt Offerings, if Burnt Offerings had been written by Grady Hendrix. Great book for spooky season; give it a read!
Sarah Hackbarth
Jan 30, 2026
8/10 stars
I felt so many things reading this book…. I laughed, cried, almost threw up, was scared, doubted the reliability of the narrator, and found myself rooting for ghosts. Thoroughly enjoyable!
Sheryl Bagwell
Jan 25, 2026
8/10 stars
I rather enjoyed this book. I'll admit i was kept guessing through the whole book...was the house truly haunted and the ghosts real or was Margeret just losing her mind? Very entertaining and great story telling. I almost gave it 5 stars, but that is reserved for books I enjoyed so much I would read them again. or for books that left me thinking about them long after I was done or had some profound effect on me. I still very much enjoyed this book.
Gias_BookHaven
Dec 30, 2025
9/10 stars
The September House will pull readers into a mysterious, quirky narrative that's strongly driven by dark humor, in my opinion, based on the situation with Margaret in her house. 

It's told in first person and Margaret's nonchalant approach and perspective for her time in this odd, creepy and clearly haunted house filled with "pranksters" as she likes to call them is clearly not of a person who scares easily. Readers get to know Margret and learn about a lot of the hard times she's endured. But we also learn about the previous souls who lived there. And as described through her eyes, the "pranksters" actually really aren't all that bad. 

And the manor of which the author humanizes them led me to believe the intention of the book was meant to be on the dark humor more than horror. 

I think that the pacing of the book is done very well, and each chapter ties into Margaret, and Hal's marriage and their relationship with the new house really came together well. Made it an enjoyable read. 

A lot of the time in each chapter I  I found myself questioning Margaret's sanity and her control over reality. She said that Hal also noticed things in the house BUT since the POV is in first person I can't fully trust her interpretation of everything; there were also moments when it felt like the events of the house with the pranksters of the house that, as Margret calls them, made everything seem like it was actually happening. 

Like the actions/events were concrete. Therefore the author will keep the readers questioning until the very end of the book whether it is real or the September house is just a figment of Margaret's imagination. 

I don't think the horror element really kicks in until the last fourth of the book and I think that , there are more creepy elements that happen in the book overall. Especially with the use of the phrases "he's down there" in reference to Master Vale and how Margaret saw notions of that outside of the house.

Again, with it being in first person, readers cannot trust if what Margret's seeing is actually reality or just figment of her imagination. Without giving spoilers, I will say that I was very pleased with the way the ending is tied up because , it got to a point in the narrative where the word "crazy" was being tossed around and signs were pointing to Margret being commItted. I didn't like the angle of it being a psychosis issue rather than something factual. Not only because this is a red flag trope for me and it is never really done well when it comes to individual having some sort of psychosis leading to them having erratic behavior. 

But <spoiler> also due to the fact that we learn a lot of what Margaret went through with her relationship with Hal and The abuse, and his alcoholism. In the beginning, I got the interpretation that how and Catherine did not have a connection because he didn't like the fact that she was a lesbian but as we continue through the book more and more details of the past is revealed. </spoiler>
daph_78
Nov 14, 2025
10/10 stars
OMG 100000/10.

See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.

More books by this author