The Mystery Writer: A Novel

2024 Mary Higgins Clark Edgar Award Nominee
"A mischievous twist on mystery novels and the people who write them." -- Benjamin Stevenson, author of Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone and Everyone on the Train is a Suspect
There's nothing easier to dismiss than a conspiracy theory--until it turns out to be true
From 2023 Edgar Award nominee and bestselling author Sulari Gentill comes a literary thriller about an aspiring writer who meets and falls in love with her literary idol--only to find him murdered the day after she gave him her manuscript to read.
When Theodosia Benton abandons her career path as an attorney and shows up on her brother's doorstep with two suitcases and an unfinished novel, she expects to face a few challenges. Will her brother support her ambition or send her back to finish her degree? What will her parents say when they learn of her decision? Does she even have what it takes to be a successful writer?
What Theo never expects is to be drawn into a hidden literary world in which identity is something that can be lost and remade for the sake of an audience. When her mentor, a highly successful author, is brutally murdered, Theo wants the killer to be found and justice to be served. Then the police begin looking at her brother, Gus, as their prime suspect, and Theo does the unthinkable in order to protect him. But the writer has left a trail, a thread out of the labyrinth in the form of a story. Gus finds that thread and follows it, and in his attempt to save his sister he inadvertently threatens the foundations of the labyrinth itself. To protect the carefully constructed narrative, Theo Benton, and everyone looking for her, will have to die.
BUY THE BOOK
Community Reviews
Theodosia “Theo” Benton is a twenty-two year old who was attending the University of Canberra Law School. She finally realizes that this was not the career path that she wanted and decides to quit and move to Lawrence, Kansas where her brother, Gus lives and works as a partner in a law firm.
Theo wants to pursue a writing career. Gus is delighted to see his little sister and has her live with him and his dog named horse.
Theo settles into her daily writing sessions at a nearby coffee shop, where other writers do the same. Theo meets a well-known writer, Dan Murdoch. He comes her mentor and eventually they start a relationship. Theo invites Dan over for dinner to meet Gus, when she arrives at Dan’s she stumbles upon Dan’s murder. Now Theo is the number one suspect. With Gus and his coworkers fighting for Theo's innocence, and then all of a sudden Theo goes missing. Is she on the run or has something more sinister happened to her?
The book still kept me entertained and even though I had an idea what had happened, it still made me question myself if I was mistaken.
My thanks to Poisoned Pen Press, The Author, Sulari Gentill as well as NetGalley, for the opportunity to read and review an early copy of The Mystery Writer.
Theo wants to pursue a writing career. Gus is delighted to see his little sister and has her live with him and his dog named horse.
Theo settles into her daily writing sessions at a nearby coffee shop, where other writers do the same. Theo meets a well-known writer, Dan Murdoch. He comes her mentor and eventually they start a relationship. Theo invites Dan over for dinner to meet Gus, when she arrives at Dan’s she stumbles upon Dan’s murder. Now Theo is the number one suspect. With Gus and his coworkers fighting for Theo's innocence, and then all of a sudden Theo goes missing. Is she on the run or has something more sinister happened to her?
The book still kept me entertained and even though I had an idea what had happened, it still made me question myself if I was mistaken.
My thanks to Poisoned Pen Press, The Author, Sulari Gentill as well as NetGalley, for the opportunity to read and review an early copy of The Mystery Writer.
As a fan of The Woman in the Library, I was curious to see what Sulari Gentill would write next. Initially, I felt off kilter and was wondering if this was the book for me. But then I remembered I felt the same way with TWITL, so I stuck with it. The plot is convoluted. Theo gives up on college and shows up on her brother’s front porch in Lawrence, Kansas. She’s decided she wants to be a writer. Hanging out in a local cafe/bar, she befriends an established writer. But no sooner have they become romantically involved, that she finds his dead body in his house. Interspersed with this storyline, the reader is privy to a group of conspiracy theory nutjobs and their messaging. It would be easy to say this group was too crazy to be believable. But our family has a QAnon idiot in our midst, and some of her theories are so unreal as to beggar belief.
I struggled to relate to Theo. I had to keep reminding myself that she was still very young and maybe not wise enough to know what she was signing up for. But would someone smart enough to get into law school really be so dumb? There were numerous times that she just seemed oblivious. it was so obvious that something was fishy with Day Delos & Associates from her very first meeting with them. Flip side, I really enjoyed Gus and Mac and appreciated what a great big brother Gus was. And Mac’s doomsday prepper family did help provide comic relief. I would have actually liked it if they had played a bigger role in the story.
Despite my issues with Theo, I did get drawn in and was curious to see how it was going to play out. I found myself reaching for the book whenever I had a spare minute. It moved at a nice brisk pace with lots of moving parts. But the last section of the book just went totally off the rails for me. It was all I could do to stay with it. The book went from being a four star to a two star. I’ll think twice before picking up her next book.
My thanks to Netgalley and Poison Pen Press for an advance copy of this book.
I struggled to relate to Theo. I had to keep reminding myself that she was still very young and maybe not wise enough to know what she was signing up for. But would someone smart enough to get into law school really be so dumb? There were numerous times that she just seemed oblivious. it was so obvious that something was fishy with Day Delos & Associates from her very first meeting with them. Flip side, I really enjoyed Gus and Mac and appreciated what a great big brother Gus was. And Mac’s doomsday prepper family did help provide comic relief. I would have actually liked it if they had played a bigger role in the story.
Despite my issues with Theo, I did get drawn in and was curious to see how it was going to play out. I found myself reaching for the book whenever I had a spare minute. It moved at a nice brisk pace with lots of moving parts. But the last section of the book just went totally off the rails for me. It was all I could do to stay with it. The book went from being a four star to a two star. I’ll think twice before picking up her next book.
My thanks to Netgalley and Poison Pen Press for an advance copy of this book.
Having enjoyed Woman in the Library, I’ve been looking forward to finally getting to read this one. One of the things that I enjoyed about Woman in the Library was the story around the story, writers writing about writers. It was this notion that I had in my head from the get-go as I delved into this story with a very similar storyline/plot.
The very first sentence of the book summary is kind of a spoiler, “There's nothing easier to dismiss than a conspiracy theory—until it turns out to be true”. So, from the get-go, I’m thinking, “ok, it’s about a conspiracy theory that’s actually true”. The rest of the book summary basically just introduces the main characters siblings, Theo and Gus (a lawyer) and how the story started, so I’m not going to repeat any of that here. What the book summary doesn’t mention is Gus’s friend and co-worker, Mac, who is an investigator at Gus’s law firm. It also doesn’t mention how this “conspiracy theory” started and that mystery is in itself a potential conspiracy theory compliments of the conspiracy theory trolls that live online fanning the flames of conspiracy theory nonsense.
There is also a secondary storyline that the book summary alludes to and that is that there is some event in Theo and Gus’s past (back in Tasmania) that the family had buried and has been hiding ever since. This is just one of the catalysts for Theo’s act of protecting Gus. Also, it doesn’t help that Mac comes from a somewhat nefarious family of doomsday preppers, whose suspicious behavior has been on law enforcement’s radar for a very long time. Personally, I’ve always found these people to be some of the wackier types of conspiracy theorists. JMHO
Most of the story flips back and forth between Theo and the online posts of a bunch of conspiracy theorists that revolve around what happened to another member of the forum that they refer to as Primus, who they believe is Dan Murdoch, who was Theo’s mentor/lover that was murdered. The conspiracy theorists believe Primus’s postings were revealing another conspiracy theory regarding a book he was posting about that would reveal another conspiracy. Getting the picture now? Yeah, me neither, but it does make the story more interesting. Anyway, none of this is a spoiler since it all transpires pretty early in the story.
The second half takes a crazy turn and that is where a good chunk of the story goes off the rails. For me, I actually like crazy twists and turns; my enjoyment of a story is not contingent of a story’s level of believability. Unfortunately, it’s not long before the ending begins to become just a humongous, hot mess, which is the same issue that I felt Woman in the Library had too. I really dislike messy endings; they’re kind of a pet peeve of mine. It’s really sad when a writer spends a lot of time, energy and effort creating a good storyline and developing interesting characters only to get to the end of the story and just kind of lets the whole story go up in a blaze, and not in the glorious kind of way either.
The elements of a story that has the most effect on my overall enjoyment of a story are strong characters, interesting storylines, a pace that keeps me engaged and the author’s writing style, which for me includes how well the writing flows and how a writer wraps up the story. Based on the first three elements, I’d give this book a 3.5star rating, if I could. When vacillating about whether or not to round up or down on a story, I rarely feel inclined to round up on stories with clunky, messy endings. This is the case here. I want to thank NetGalley, Poisoned Pen Press for sending me this eARC in exchange for my honest review.
#NetGalley #PoisonedPress #TheMysteryWriter
The very first sentence of the book summary is kind of a spoiler, “There's nothing easier to dismiss than a conspiracy theory—until it turns out to be true”. So, from the get-go, I’m thinking, “ok, it’s about a conspiracy theory that’s actually true”. The rest of the book summary basically just introduces the main characters siblings, Theo and Gus (a lawyer) and how the story started, so I’m not going to repeat any of that here. What the book summary doesn’t mention is Gus’s friend and co-worker, Mac, who is an investigator at Gus’s law firm. It also doesn’t mention how this “conspiracy theory” started and that mystery is in itself a potential conspiracy theory compliments of the conspiracy theory trolls that live online fanning the flames of conspiracy theory nonsense.
There is also a secondary storyline that the book summary alludes to and that is that there is some event in Theo and Gus’s past (back in Tasmania) that the family had buried and has been hiding ever since. This is just one of the catalysts for Theo’s act of protecting Gus. Also, it doesn’t help that Mac comes from a somewhat nefarious family of doomsday preppers, whose suspicious behavior has been on law enforcement’s radar for a very long time. Personally, I’ve always found these people to be some of the wackier types of conspiracy theorists. JMHO
Most of the story flips back and forth between Theo and the online posts of a bunch of conspiracy theorists that revolve around what happened to another member of the forum that they refer to as Primus, who they believe is Dan Murdoch, who was Theo’s mentor/lover that was murdered. The conspiracy theorists believe Primus’s postings were revealing another conspiracy theory regarding a book he was posting about that would reveal another conspiracy. Getting the picture now? Yeah, me neither, but it does make the story more interesting. Anyway, none of this is a spoiler since it all transpires pretty early in the story.
The second half takes a crazy turn and that is where a good chunk of the story goes off the rails. For me, I actually like crazy twists and turns; my enjoyment of a story is not contingent of a story’s level of believability. Unfortunately, it’s not long before the ending begins to become just a humongous, hot mess, which is the same issue that I felt Woman in the Library had too. I really dislike messy endings; they’re kind of a pet peeve of mine. It’s really sad when a writer spends a lot of time, energy and effort creating a good storyline and developing interesting characters only to get to the end of the story and just kind of lets the whole story go up in a blaze, and not in the glorious kind of way either.
The elements of a story that has the most effect on my overall enjoyment of a story are strong characters, interesting storylines, a pace that keeps me engaged and the author’s writing style, which for me includes how well the writing flows and how a writer wraps up the story. Based on the first three elements, I’d give this book a 3.5star rating, if I could. When vacillating about whether or not to round up or down on a story, I rarely feel inclined to round up on stories with clunky, messy endings. This is the case here. I want to thank NetGalley, Poisoned Pen Press for sending me this eARC in exchange for my honest review.
#NetGalley #PoisonedPress #TheMysteryWriter
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC of this book!
I really enjoyed the premise and the mix of conspiracy theory forums with different third person perspectives throughout the book. The main characters were all likable and I liked that the background of the characters wasn’t homogenous (even if some of them were a little outlandish, it didn’t feel unbelievable).
My only qualms are that it felt like it resolved too quickly and neatly vs how slow it was in the beginning (I.e. pacing issues) and some of the details felt a bit unnecessary to the overall story. If some of these details were moved it could have improved the pacing if the climax wasn’t squeezed right at the end.
Overall, the reading experience had me on the edge of my seat so it’s a 4/5 for the minor issues mentioned above.
I really enjoyed the premise and the mix of conspiracy theory forums with different third person perspectives throughout the book. The main characters were all likable and I liked that the background of the characters wasn’t homogenous (even if some of them were a little outlandish, it didn’t feel unbelievable).
My only qualms are that it felt like it resolved too quickly and neatly vs how slow it was in the beginning (I.e. pacing issues) and some of the details felt a bit unnecessary to the overall story. If some of these details were moved it could have improved the pacing if the climax wasn’t squeezed right at the end.
Overall, the reading experience had me on the edge of my seat so it’s a 4/5 for the minor issues mentioned above.
I thought the book had a unique plot that was executed well. The character development was interesting and the ending was satisfying. I appreciated the fourth wall breaking element in the conclusion, which hinted that the book itself was a product of the story. Among the characters, I particularly enjoyed Mac and his conservative doomsday survivalist family. The book had a lot of world building and personality, making it an enjoyable read. I would definitely read more from this author.