Only Love Can Hurt Like This

AN EARTH SHATTERING SECRET. A LIFE-CHANGING LOVE STORY.

“Nobody writes angst and joy and hope like Paige Toon.”—CHRISTINA LAUREN, author of LOVE AND OTHER WORDS

For fans of Colleen Hoover, an unforgettable and heartbreaking love story with an earth-shattering secret at its core that asks the question: Is love worth risking everything for?


When Wren realizes her fiancé is in love with someone else, she thinks her heart will never recover.

On the other side of the world, Anders lost his wife four years ago and is still struggling to move on.

Wren hopes that spending the summer with her dad and step-family on their farm in Indiana will help her to heal. There, amid the cornfields and fireflies, she and Anders cross paths and their worlds are turned upside-down again.

But Wren doesn't know that Anders is harboring a secret, and if he acts on any feelings he has for Wren it will have serious fall-out for everyone. Walking away would hurt Wren more than she can imagine. But, knowing the truth, how can she possibly stay?

BUY THE BOOK

Published Apr 25, 2023

400 pages

Average rating: 7.58

59 RATINGS

|

Community Reviews

literarily_occupied
Aug 12, 2025
8/10 stars
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ / 4 stars

This is one of those books where when you start reading, you don't want to put it down. I was immediately drawn in to this story and connected with these characters so quickly.

It's an achingly slow burn that brought me to tears on more than one occasion. While the love story was a bit predictable I was still completely invested and emotionally moved.

The only real critique I have is that the epilogue felt so different from the rest of the story. It just didn't flow as well and felt overly long.

This was my first read by the author and I would definitely consider reading more from her.

Thank you to NetGalley, G.P. Putnam's Sons, and the author for this complimentary digital copy in exchange for an honest review.
mamaShara
Aug 23, 2024
10/10 stars
OMG -- simply fabulous read. This was my 1st Paige Toon book and I'm totally in love. Frantically trying to find the rest of her books. Wonderful storyteller. Well developed characters, loving and real relationships between them all. I was left totally wanting more from this story. Please grab this book and start your own love affair with this author. I cannot wait to expand my library with all of her amazing stories.
CharleyB
Apr 06, 2024
5/10 stars
Eh. Very slow until about page 300. It was a good ending but not a stand out book. 5/10
Precious
Dec 03, 2023
7/10 stars
I didn’t hate this but definitely didn’t love it! I was just expecting more but definitely great read!
Holcol
Nov 01, 2023
7/10 stars
Much slower paced than i was expecting but the ending made up for it

See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.