Only Love Can Break Your Heart: A Novel

"A lush mystery-within-a-coming-of-age-tale-within-a-Southern-Gothic." --NPR Books

"A richly textured portrait of small-town dysfunction and murder . . . Secrets abound, imaginations run wild." --The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Welcome to Spencerville, Virginia, 1977. Eight-year-old Rocky worships his older brother, Paul. Sixteen and full of rebel cool, Paul spends his days cruising in his Chevy Nova blasting Neil Young, cigarette dangling from his lips, arm slung around his beautiful, troubled girlfriend. Paul is happy to have his younger brother as his sidekick. Then one day, in an act of vengeance against their father, Paul picks up Rocky from school and nearly abandons him in the woods. Afterward, Paul disappears.

Seven years later, Rocky is a teenager himself. He hasn't forgotten being abandoned by his boyhood hero, but he's getting over it, with the help of the wealthy neighbors' daughter, ten years his senior, who has taken him as her lover. Unbeknownst to both of them, their affair will set in motion a course of events that rains catastrophe on both their families. After a mysterious double murder brings terror and suspicion to their small town, Rocky and his family must reckon with the past and find out how much forgiveness their hearts can hold.

BUY THE BOOK

Published Nov 15, 2016

336 pages

Average rating: 7.4

5 RATINGS

|

Community Reviews

nfmgirl
Mar 08, 2026
8/10 stars
This was a sort of off-beat story, quirky, a little jumbled. Some book club members complained that it was as if the author threw in everything but the kitchen sink. I liked the story well enough, but it was a bit YA "coming-of-age". We found in our book club discussion that it is one of those books with moments you don't fully understand, and then someone will explain, "No, remember he..." and someone else will say "Oh! I missed that!" or "Oh, I thought..." There's a lot going on, and it's easy to miss or misunderstand little things. But this is a good pick for those who like coming-of-age stories. Rounded up from 3.5 stars
abookwanderer
Oct 09, 2025
8/10 stars
*I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

A coming-of-age book, this beautifully written novel has a bit of everything: humor, suspense, heartbreak, and hope. Young Rocky idolizes his older brother, Paul, but when strife within the home leads to Paul's disappearance, Rocky is left with more questions than answers. Rocky leads the reader down a twisting tale of his life, and how the people who come in and out of it shape the man he ultimately becomes.
Marydaleo
Dec 28, 2023
4/10 stars
Meh. A little dramatic with too many loose ends hastily snipped off at the end. A well-written story, but nothing life-changing. Perhaps a good beach read, if you like to be sad at the beach.

See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.