My Favorite Terrible Thing: A Novel

The world's most famous author has vanished. A thrilling hunt of mind games and twisting suspense begins when a detective sees evidence written into her novel.

Detective Nina Travers is so good at her job that she blends in like a benevolent Tom Ripley. She can be anyone. She can be no one. Nina wants to be someone. Her new case will finally get her noticed.

Bestselling author Claire Ross has disappeared from the Hamptons on her wedding day. How tragic that the author of an epic romance that captured the heart, soul, and imagination of the world should suddenly vanish on the happiest day of her life. Claire's distraught family and friends, her mystified fiancé, and her zealous online fans all have their theories--from the sinister to the hopeful. Nina's job is to find the truth, and she's pursuing an angle that no one else has explored. She's looking for a trail of clues in Claire's novel.

Reading between its haunting lines, Nina follows a spiraling path of secret love, obsession, and death. What Nina finds is so shocking even she never saw it coming.

BUY THE BOOK

Published May 1, 2024

301 pages

Average rating: 6.08

13 RATINGS

|

Community Reviews

carrmel21
Feb 26, 2025
10/10 stars
My Favorite Terrible Thing by Madeleine Henry is a masterclass in suspense and intrigue. From the moment I picked up this book, I was drawn into the world of Detective Nina Travers and the mysterious disappearance of bestselling author Claire Ross. The novel’s blend of mystery and psychological depth is nothing short of brilliant.

Henry’s writing is sharp and evocative, crafting a story that is as much about the characters’ inner demons as it is about the external mystery. The way she weaves the narrative through the clues hidden in Claire’s novel is ingenious, keeping me guessing at every turn. The exploration of toxic fan culture and the dark side of literary fame adds a compelling layer to the plot that resonates in today’s celebrity-obsessed society.

This book is a triumph of storytelling, with twists that left me shocked and a conclusion that was both satisfying and unexpected. It’s a thrilling hunt through mind games and twisting suspense that had me riveted until the very last page. For anyone who loves a good thriller that challenges the mind and tugs at the heartstrings, My Favorite Terrible Thing is an absolute must-read
Lyriana
Jun 16, 2024
8/10 stars
This book is ... unique. I liked it over-all. It's a little meandering and at times a little unbelievable, but nicely written. And it's much more of a mystery than most of the 'mystery' novels that are being written today.

Not perfect, but I liked it.

See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.