Community Reviews
thenextgoodboook.com
What’s it about?
This historical novel is loosely based on the life of Marguerite de la Rocque de Roberval, a sixteenth-century French noblewoman. She was deserted on an island off the coast of Canada sometime in the 1540s and is said to have lived there for two years. In this version, Marguerite is a spoiled and lonely orphan who is totally at the mercy of her male guardian. When he spends all of her inheritance, she has no recourse but to follow him on an expedition to New France.
What did it make me think about?
This story certainly makes you understand how powerless women have been throughout history.
Should I read it?
I find most historical fiction falls into two categories. One category writes a fairly straightforward story that conveys some historical context or story to the reader. The other group of books falls into a more literary category. These books appear to be pieces of literature that incorporate history. I would put this book in the latter category. I read Kaaterskill Falls and The Family Markowitz ages ago, and I remember enjoying them both. I read SAM and reviewed it a couple of years ago, and although I was less enthusiastic, I still enjoyed the book. But this novel felt like a big departure for Allegra Goodman. It was neither a sprawling family drama nor a contemporary story. I am always impressed when an author shows such flexibility. It was not what I expected, but it provided a compelling glimpse into the life of a privileged woman in the mid-1500s. Anyone who enjoys historical fiction is in for a treat.
Quote-
“I knew as little of the chateau’s public rooms as I did of my farms and vineyards, for like all my property, they were mine in name only.”
“I turned to Auguste, and I thought how rare he was to believe and yet to doubt-to entertain both.”
What’s it about?
This historical novel is loosely based on the life of Marguerite de la Rocque de Roberval, a sixteenth-century French noblewoman. She was deserted on an island off the coast of Canada sometime in the 1540s and is said to have lived there for two years. In this version, Marguerite is a spoiled and lonely orphan who is totally at the mercy of her male guardian. When he spends all of her inheritance, she has no recourse but to follow him on an expedition to New France.
What did it make me think about?
This story certainly makes you understand how powerless women have been throughout history.
Should I read it?
I find most historical fiction falls into two categories. One category writes a fairly straightforward story that conveys some historical context or story to the reader. The other group of books falls into a more literary category. These books appear to be pieces of literature that incorporate history. I would put this book in the latter category. I read Kaaterskill Falls and The Family Markowitz ages ago, and I remember enjoying them both. I read SAM and reviewed it a couple of years ago, and although I was less enthusiastic, I still enjoyed the book. But this novel felt like a big departure for Allegra Goodman. It was neither a sprawling family drama nor a contemporary story. I am always impressed when an author shows such flexibility. It was not what I expected, but it provided a compelling glimpse into the life of a privileged woman in the mid-1500s. Anyone who enjoys historical fiction is in for a treat.
Quote-
“I knew as little of the chateau’s public rooms as I did of my farms and vineyards, for like all my property, they were mine in name only.”
“I turned to Auguste, and I thought how rare he was to believe and yet to doubt-to entertain both.”
Inspired by the true story of Marguerite de la Roche in the 1500s, we follow the main character orphaned and put under the care of her cousin guardian. Always muted by the decisions of males, and peers, Marguerite is thrown into a life of submission. From constantly being robbed of her riches from her guardian, from being hushed into secretly hiding her romance with her true love, and reduce to always putting up the front of her caste and stature, we follow Marguerite trying to survive and keep her faith/virtue. This would be a great book club read. Plenty of topics with good twists.
Really good historical fiction based on a real woman, similar to By Any Other Name or The Familiar. I didn’t know the novel was based on a true story and wish I had before I started reading. I did get a little bogged down by the focus on Christian faith and the heroine’s “conversion” so to speak. But, I am sure that kind of dependence on the Bible and faith was true to the time period.
A story of courage and faith in which a woman overcomes adversity and learns her strength through her struggles.
See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.