Good Dirt: A Novel

NATIONAL BESTSELLER • The daughter of an affluent Black family pieces together the connection between a childhood tragedy and a beloved heirloom in this moving novel from the bestselling author of Black Cake, a Read with Jenna Book Club Pick
BUY THE BOOK
Community Reviews
What Bookclubbers are saying about this book
✨ Summarized by Bookclubs AI
Readers say *Good Dirt* by Charmaine Wilkerson is a multi-generational family saga that links history, identity, and moral responsibility through symb...
I really enjoyed this book. I love books that go back and forth between the past and the present, and I love historical fiction. Some of the retelling of the enslaved family members really broke my heart, but It was needed to connect the readers to the main character's family's love of their heirloom.
What in heaven’s name did I just read? Was it romance, historical fiction, family drama or mystery? The beginning of Good Dirt starts off like a typical romance novel and my first thought was, please, Lord, no. Not a romance by the author who wrote Black Cake. Ebby Freeman has already endured one tragedy, the murder of her brother when she was ten. But when her rich white fiancée leaves her at the altar, her life goes off course again. She accepts the offer of a friend to live at her French guest house as a caretaker. So, who is the first visitor to the place? Her ex, with his latest flame.
But the book soon delves in other directions. Across multiple time periods and POVs, it covers an African woman sold into slavery, whose son creates a large stoneware jug. This jug, decorated by one of Ebby’s ancestors, becomes a family heirloom when he escapes north with the jug. We also hear from Ebby’s parents, the ex-fiancée, even his latest paramour. There were so many POVs and so many different storylines, it took me a while to get oriented. I would advise those who feel put off by the beginning to stick with it. Because it does draw you in. The characters were interesting and multi-dimensional. Even Henry, who was a total jerk and a wuss, had the good sense to realize what an ass he was.
At the heart of the story is moving on from trauma. It’s about being willing to have the difficult conversations, to being an adult. And it’s about how not just our individual past, but also our family stories, shapes us.
As with Black Cake, the writing here is luscious; meant to be savored.
My thanks to Netgalley and Random House for an advance copy of this book.
But the book soon delves in other directions. Across multiple time periods and POVs, it covers an African woman sold into slavery, whose son creates a large stoneware jug. This jug, decorated by one of Ebby’s ancestors, becomes a family heirloom when he escapes north with the jug. We also hear from Ebby’s parents, the ex-fiancée, even his latest paramour. There were so many POVs and so many different storylines, it took me a while to get oriented. I would advise those who feel put off by the beginning to stick with it. Because it does draw you in. The characters were interesting and multi-dimensional. Even Henry, who was a total jerk and a wuss, had the good sense to realize what an ass he was.
At the heart of the story is moving on from trauma. It’s about being willing to have the difficult conversations, to being an adult. And it’s about how not just our individual past, but also our family stories, shapes us.
As with Black Cake, the writing here is luscious; meant to be savored.
My thanks to Netgalley and Random House for an advance copy of this book.
I'll be honest: the first paragraph of chapter one made me pause. I thought, I just finished a hard book, do I really have it in me to keep going?
I am so glad I did.
This is a book that asks you to sit with hard truths. It doesn’t rush you past them or soften them for comfort. Instead, it trusts the reader to stay, to listen, and to reckon. People need to read this book.
At its heart, Good Dirt is about family, loss, inheritance, and what holds us together when the past refuses to stay quiet. It demands us to pay attention to the fact that history isn’t something that belongs neatly to “someone else.” One of the most striking ideas running through the book is this:
People believe that her history is not their history too.
But it is. Whether we claim it or not.
The novel asks an uncomfortable question: What kind of history are we choosing to carry forward? One rooted in silence, denial, and violence or one shaped by accountability, truth, and repair?
What I loved most is that, even in its heaviness, the book never loses sight of humanity. We are reminded that people are wired to persevere. People hurt, yes, but they still laugh. They still love. They still hope. When the weight of history feels like too much, the message isn’t to give up, it’s to find your outlet and keep going.
Another powerful thread is moral responsibility. When faced with wrongdoing, it’s easier to deflect, to blame, to look away. But we shouldn't be let off that easily. We need ownership. If you make a mistake, own it, correct it, and don’t keep repeating it. Silence isn’t neutral here, it’s a choice. And looking away is its own form of participation.
The historical passages, especially those referencing violence and voter suppression during Reconstruction, land with chilling clarity. You don’t have to stretch to make the connections to now.
She needed a soft reentry. Girl. Same.
This book asks a lot of the reader. It stirs grief, anger, reflection, and resolve. You may need to put it down and breathe. That’s okay. Come back when you’re ready.
Good Dirt is not an easy read, but it is a necessary one. Thoughtful, timely, and deeply human, it stays with you long after the final page.
I was excited to read this book because it is the same author as Black Cake. Wilkerson does a great job of weaving together a present-day story that starts with a tragedy and a story of slavery and racism. Time stopped for 10-year-old Ebby Freeman when she heard the shot that killed her brother and shattered a family heirloom (a stoneware jar). The Freemans are one of the only Black families in a well to do New England neighborhood. The crime is never solved and years later, after Ebby's high profile engagements falls apart, her family is once again in the spotlight. Ebby flees to France, but the past seems to follow her. Ebby is not only processing her loss (brother, romance and family treasure) but the loss her parents suffered as well. Soon Ebby realizes the jar contains more than just her family's history.
The past and the present are told through multiple perspectives. This is a well written character driven story with many themes: grief, slavery, racism, ancestry, inheritance and the importance of respecting history to understand our present. We inherit the stories of our past and can use them to shape our future. I also really liked the short chapters! So 4 ⭐️ because it does have a lot of storylines. Overall, I really liked it!
The past and the present are told through multiple perspectives. This is a well written character driven story with many themes: grief, slavery, racism, ancestry, inheritance and the importance of respecting history to understand our present. We inherit the stories of our past and can use them to shape our future. I also really liked the short chapters! So 4 ⭐️ because it does have a lot of storylines. Overall, I really liked it!
I really enjoyed the historical narrative of the "Old Mo" jar, but I found the modern romantic subplot to be lacking. I tend to read more historical fiction than romance, which could be a reason it just fell flat for me.