Community Reviews
This is hard to rate. Firstly I haven't read all chapters and don't plan to, but I will read more.
I was actually expecting this to be an overly technical intro like most handbooks that are basically unreadable as the authors try to act overly intellectual by using confusing sentences and words to sound academic. Here it's nearly the opposite. Each chapter is actually a light encyclopedia-like intro to the topic at hand. No matter if you want to read about the history or about adults with ADHD you will get exactly what you seek. The topic itself presented in a short and accessible format. Though because it is clinical psychology, a field of research that is extremely arbitrary and often unscientific, you get what you expect: a subject that is light on proper science and evidence.
The chapters also feel a bit too basic and unspecific. Again, the author is most often not to blame it's just that clinical psychology is an extremely iffy field with a ton of pseudoscientific claims. He uses whatever studies he can find on each subject, which is hundreds, and then fills out the gaps with his own ideas and opinions that are on a very accessible yet intellectual level. The history part for example does go over most of the history and years yet there are basically zero quotes or tables. So unless you already know the history there is no way you can understand what people were thinking at what point without seeing a single drawing or citation from those periods. It's all extremely shallow. Sure, he mentions it all. But just mentioning something doesn't mean readers will get it the same way he understands it. This book feels like a book made for students to quote for exams without understanding anything.
As an intro for an unscientific topic like ADHD this is really good and you won't find much better intros out there if you understand the scientific method and how studies are conducted. But it still feels a bit hazy and I'm not sure I understand ADHD after reading chapters from the book. Maybe I could read a basic overview in an audiobook format from the author and then understand some of the unsaid stuff here. Honestly a documentary or image-filled book format would have worked better than pure text as this is very much focused on unscientific historical claims.
I was actually expecting this to be an overly technical intro like most handbooks that are basically unreadable as the authors try to act overly intellectual by using confusing sentences and words to sound academic. Here it's nearly the opposite. Each chapter is actually a light encyclopedia-like intro to the topic at hand. No matter if you want to read about the history or about adults with ADHD you will get exactly what you seek. The topic itself presented in a short and accessible format. Though because it is clinical psychology, a field of research that is extremely arbitrary and often unscientific, you get what you expect: a subject that is light on proper science and evidence.
The chapters also feel a bit too basic and unspecific. Again, the author is most often not to blame it's just that clinical psychology is an extremely iffy field with a ton of pseudoscientific claims. He uses whatever studies he can find on each subject, which is hundreds, and then fills out the gaps with his own ideas and opinions that are on a very accessible yet intellectual level. The history part for example does go over most of the history and years yet there are basically zero quotes or tables. So unless you already know the history there is no way you can understand what people were thinking at what point without seeing a single drawing or citation from those periods. It's all extremely shallow. Sure, he mentions it all. But just mentioning something doesn't mean readers will get it the same way he understands it. This book feels like a book made for students to quote for exams without understanding anything.
As an intro for an unscientific topic like ADHD this is really good and you won't find much better intros out there if you understand the scientific method and how studies are conducted. But it still feels a bit hazy and I'm not sure I understand ADHD after reading chapters from the book. Maybe I could read a basic overview in an audiobook format from the author and then understand some of the unsaid stuff here. Honestly a documentary or image-filled book format would have worked better than pure text as this is very much focused on unscientific historical claims.
