Create your account image
Book of the month

Reading this title?

JOIN BOOKCLUBS
Buy the book
Discussion Guide

What Storm, What Thunder

A Buzzfeed, Washington Post, Good Housekeeping, Vulture, & Library Journal Best Book of Fall

 

“Sublime. A striking and formidable novel by one of our most brilliant writers and storytellers.”  ―Edwidge Danticat

 

The earth had buckled and, in that movement, all that was not in its place fell upon the earth’s children, upon the blameless as well as the guilty, without discrimination.

 

At the end of a long, sweltering day, as markets and businesses begin to close for the evening, an earthquake of 7.0 magnitude shakes the capital of Haiti, Port-au-Prince. Award-winning author Myriam J. A. Chancy masterfully charts the inner lives of the characters affected by the disaster―Richard, an expat and wealthy water-bottling executive with a secret daughter; the daughter, Anne, an architect who drafts affordable housing structures for a global NGO; a small-time drug trafficker, Leopold, who pines for a beautiful call girl; Sonia and her business partner, Dieudonné, who are followed by a man they believe is the vodou spirit of death; Didier, an emigrant musician who drives a taxi in Boston; Sara, a mother haunted by the ghosts of her children in an IDP camp; her husband, Olivier, an accountant forced to abandon the wife he loves; their son, Jonas, who haunts them both; and Ma Lou, the old woman selling produce in the market who remembers them all. Artfully weaving together these lives, witness is given to the desolation wreaked by nature and by man.


Brilliantly crafted, fiercely imagined, and deeply haunting, What Storm, What Thunder is a singular, stunning record, a reckoning of the heartbreaking trauma of disaster, and―at the same time―an unforgettable testimony to the tenacity of the human spirit.


This discussion guide and recommended reading was shared and sponsored in partnership with Tin House.

Book club questions for What Storm, What Thunder by Myriam JA Chancy

Use these discussion questions to guide your next book club meeting.

Why do you think Myriam J.A. Chancy chose Ma Lou to frame the story?
Which character in What Storm, What Thunder do you most identify with? Which do you least identify with and why?
How do you react to the death of Richard? of Olivier? Could their deaths have been avoided?
How do violence and tenderness coexist in the makeshift relief camps in Haiti?
What takeaways do you think might stay with you were you to face a natural disaster in the future?
What Storm, What Thunder creates a multi-voiced narrative of the earthquake through the experience of related and interrelated characters. If you and your family or friends were to live through a natural disaster of this magnitude, how do you think you or others around you would react?
The characters in What Storm, What Thunder, all experience some form of loss, especially of a sense of home. What would you miss most in terms of personal or historical landmarks if these disappeared overnight?
If you had been in Sara's shoes, how do you think you would have responded to the losses she faced?
What similarities and differences exist between siblings Didier, Sonia, Taffia and Paul, and what accounts for these? What do these reveal about generational differences or issues of class?
If you could summarize the novel's theme in one word, what would it be?

What Storm, What Thunder Book Club Questions PDF

Click here for a printable PDF of the What Storm, What Thunder discussion questions