Discussion Guide

Liar, Temptress, Soldier, Spy

By Karen Abbott

These book club questions are from the Emporia Public Library.

Book club questions for Liar, Temptress, Soldier, Spy by Karen Abbott

Use these discussion questions to guide your next book club meeting.

How many in the group recall learning about Belle Boyd, Elizabeth Van Lew, Rose O’Neal Greenhow, or Sarah Emma Edmonds prior to this book? Given their individual stories, is that surprising? Why do you think this is?
Author Karen Abbott specifically did not want to write about a single individual, instead repeatedly calling on the word tapestry to describe the weaving of multiple stories. Why do you think she chose these four women specifically?
Which of the four primary characters most fascinated you or elicited the strongest connection for you? Why?

Reading this book with your club?

Access these questions right on your club's meeting page on Bookclubs — no more copy-pasting into a group text.

Create My Club
What factors might influence how we respond to each character? Did the affiliation with North or South matter to you? Personality? Circumstances? Traditional bias toward how women should behave?
For each of the four women, what were the most memorable escapades? How effective was each in advancing her cause?
Did you feel you had good sense of what in their pasts led these women to these roles? Did any surprise you?
What made the women more effective as spies than their male counterparts?
How did the women turn societal assumptions or traditions regarding gender to their advantage?
How would you describe each character’s relationships with the men in their lives?
Which of the supporting characters made an impression? For instance, what did you think of the parts played by Jerome Robbins or Mary Bowser?
Is each word in the title intended to correspond to one of the women, or does it hold a different message?
The author’s intention was that this history read like a novel. How successful was she? What qualities support or contradict that intent?
What is gained by intertwining the four stories in a chronological structure? Would you have preferred to focus on one character at a time in four sections?
Most everyone studies the Civil War, but hardly any are taught about Civil War spies, much less women as spies. Why not? What is the value of history instruction beyond battles and traditional leaders? Would you argue for better inclusion of stories like these in general histories?

Liar, Temptress, Soldier, Spy Book Club Questions PDF

Download a printable PDF of these discussion questions to bring to your meeting.

Get discussion questions automatically for every book your club reads — free

Set Up Your Club