Create your account image
Book of the month

Reading this title?

JOIN BOOKCLUBS
Buy the book
Discussion Guide

Eva and Eve

This book of the month was shared and sponsored in partnership with Julie Metz.

Book club questions for Eva and Eve by Julie Metz

Use these discussion questions to guide your next book club meeting.

Eva and Eve is an intimate exploration of one family’s escape from Nazi-occupied Vienna. Do you have family members who lived through this time? How have you learned their stories?

For children and grandchildren of Holocaust survivors, there is often a silence around family stories of the Nazi era. If you’ve experienced this in your family, how would you go about researching your family’s history?

In Eva and Eve, the author makes use of fictional devices in parts of the narrative. Why do you think the writer chose to do this and do you think it is effective?

The Jews of Vienna, including the author’s family, felt that they belonged to their city and would remain safe. Talk about why they felt this way, even with the rise of Hitler in neighboring Germany. Do you see any parallels to our time?

Eva and Eve introduces us to three sets of mothers and children. How would you describe your connection with your own mother? What aspects of her personality do you see in yourself?

The Singer family escape was the result of a combination of persistence and what seems like random good fortune. Or was it random? Talk about the role of brief encounters in your own life, and how those changed you.

For most of us in the United States, with the exception of Native Americans, our families came from somewhere else. What is your family’s history in the United States? Did your family come by choice or as a result of persecution or enslavement? If by choice, what did they hope to find here? What did America mean to them?

The trauma of war and persecution can reverberate through generations. Do you have any experiences of this in your family?

Eva and Eve has a braided structure, interweaving the present and past. Talk about other books or films or television shows with this kind of structure and how it works in storytelling.

The Holocaust is one of the most researched events in history. What do you think we can learn from stories about the era of National Socialism in Germany and its occupied territories?

The persistence of anti-Semitism and racism in American has moved to the front pages of the news. How would you envision a constructive and positive way to discuss these issues with friends and families and your larger community?

In the book, the author describes her desire to reclaim Austrian citizenship, despite the anger her mother felt toward the country that had expelled her. She elaborates on this quest here: https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/community/articles/daughters-inheritance-austrian-passport
How do you think the author’s feelings about Austria change during the course of her research?

Eva and Eve Book Club Questions PDF

Click here for a printable PDF of the Eva and Eve discussion questions

“Julie Metz is a beautiful writer. In Eva and Eve she masterfully weaves the present with the past, the sweep of history with the deeply personal. She takes us along as she uncovers her mother’s miraculous escape from Vienna and retraces her family’s footsteps as they flee the Nazis and remake their lives as refugees. This is not just a voyage of personal discovery and a daughter’s quest to understand her mother but an evocative, heart-wrenching book about love, family and resilience.”

—Ariana Neumann, author of When Time Stopped

 

“One of the most engrossing, educational, emotional and yet effortless reads of the year so far, Eva and Eve is a stellar work of nonfiction. Weaving together multiple generations, Julie introduces us to her family and paints a vivid picture of Jewish life in Vienna prior to 1940. . . . this book is simply impossible to forget.” 

—Zibby Owens, Moms Don’t Have Time to Read Books, for Good Morning America


 

“At first, Metz feeds us teaspoons of history, but soon the force of the story itself plunges us into the violent past with a cold splash. The book is tenderly written, particularly when we are so drawn in that it can feel like we have wandered into a diary, complete with details about the weather and the bloom of nature as the scenes unfold.”

—Linda F. Burghardt, Jewish Book Council