Create your account image
Book of the month

Reading this title?

JOIN BOOKCLUBS
Buy the book
Discussion Guide

After Effects

To grieve after a profound loss is perfectly natural and healthy. To be debilitated by grief for more than a decade, as Andrea Gilats was, is something else. In her candid, deeply moving, and ultimately helpful memoir of breaking free of death’s relentless grip on her life, Gilats tells her story of living with prolonged, or “complicated,” grief and offers insight, hope, and guidance to others who suffer as she did. 

 

Thomas Dayton, Andrea Gilats’s husband of twenty years, died at 52 after a five-month battle with cancer. In After Effects Gilats describes the desolation that followed and the slow and torturous twenty-year journey that brought her back to life. In the two years immediately following his death, Gilats wrote Tom daily letters, desperately trying to maintain the twenty-year conversation of their marriage. Excerpts from these letters reveal the depth of her despair but also the glimmer of an awakening as they also trace a different, more typical course of the grief experienced by one of Gilats's colleagues, also widowed. Gilats’s struggle to rescue herself takes her through the temptation of suicide, the threat of deadly illness, the overwhelming challenges of work, and the rigor of learning and eventually teaching yoga, to a moment of reckoning and, finally, reconciliation to a life without her beloved partner. Her story is informed by the lessons she learned about complicated grief as a disorder that, while intensely personal, can be defined, grappled with, and overcome.

 

Though complicated grief affects as many as one in seven of those stricken by the loss of a close loved one, it is little known outside professional circles. After Effects points toward a path of recuperation and provides solace along the way—a service and a comfort that is all the more timely and necessary in our pandemic-ravaged world of loss and isolation.

Book club questions for After Effects by Andrea Gilats

Use these discussion questions to guide your next book club meeting.

How has reading After Effects affected your sense of empathy? Has Andrea’s story changed your feelings for people who have survived the death of a close loved one from Covid-19? What about people who have lost loved ones unexpectedly in a mass tragedy or a war? What about family members and friends who have suffered a significant loss?

How long should “normal” grief last? What factors might contribute to prolonged or complicated grief? Have you ever experienced emotions that somehow went beyond normal? Can you imagine yourself ever suffering from prolonged grief disorder?

After Tom died, Andrea lost the ability to take pleasure in activities she had always enjoyed. This can also be a sign of depression. From your personal perspective, do you feel that there are differences between grief and depression?

Do you feel that it is possible for people to recover their former state of “wholeness” after a significant loss? Why or why not?

In After Effects, Andrea writes that grief never fully fades into the past but instead becomes “a fixed part of character.” Do you agree with this statement? Why or why not?

Do you feel that Jewish mourning customs and remembrance practices affected Andrea’s experience of grief? If so, how? How might your cultural or religious heritage affect the ways you express grief? Do you feel that our deceased loved ones remain with us forever?

How did Andrea’s grief influence her reactions to important events in the world, such as the death of Senator Paul Wellstone and the election of President Barack Obama? Had she not lost Tom, do you think these events would have affected her in the same ways?

How did finding purposeful creative activities, such as painting, teaching yoga, and creating new kinds of lifelong learning programs affect Andrea’s ability to heal? From which parts of yourself do you draw strength? 

After Effects Book Club Questions PDF

Click here for a printable PDF of the After Effects discussion questions