Community Reviews
Loved it
This is my second time reading Wuthering Heights. The first was years ago, back in school, and even then I couldn't understand why so many people insisted on calling love a central theme in this book. Coming back to it now, I feel the same—only more strongly.
For me, this novel is one of those rare works that feels almost prophetic, like it doesn't just belong to its own time but reaches forward to speak across centuries. It's brutal, unflinching, and unapologetic in the way it exposes the darkest edges of human behavior. Emily Brontë never lets you hide behind excuses for these characters—she drags the ugliness out into the open and forces you to sit with it. That makes it feel less like a romance and more like a cautionary tale, startlingly ahead of its time.
The writing itself is staggering. I can feel the atmosphere pressing in from every direction—every sentence soaked in mood and tension, pulling me straight into the storm-wracked moors. The story unfolds with this relentless rhythm, and the dialogue slices through with a kind of genius-level intensity. Brontë creates a world where even silence feels heavy with consequence, and it's impossible not to absorb it.
The characters are almost impossible to love—and I think that's the whole point. They're not meant to be admired. They exist to show what obsession, cruelty, unchecked desire, and patriarchal power do when left to rot. People often call this a dark romance or a story of destructive love, but I don't see love anywhere in these pages. At best, there are fleeting flashes of compassion—but they're always measured, always conditional, never enough to cost the giver anything. If you've ever truly known love, you know it doesn't live in this book.
And that's what makes Wuthering Heights so unforgettable. It dismantles illusions. It shows, in the rawest way, that passion without compassion, desire without responsibility, isn't love at all—it's ruin. And maybe that's why the book endures: because it forces us to stare straight at the truths we'd rather blur, soften, or ignore.
Difficult but worth it
Harrowing
My favorite book from the late 18th century - Emily even beats Jane Austin in my humble opinion. I re-read this book often and can still find lines that resonate.
See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.