When the Stars Go Dark: A Novel

NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER • GOOD MORNING AMERICA BUZZ PICK • “A total departure for the author of The Paris Wife, McLain’s emotionally intense and exceptionally well-written thriller entwines its fictional crime with real cases.”—People (Book of the Week)
NAMED ONE OF THE BEST BOOKS OF THE YEAR BY MARIE CLAIRE • “The kind of heart-pounding conclusion that thriller fans crave . . . In the end, a book full of darkness lands with a message of hope.”—The New York Times Book Review
“This mystery will keep you guessing, and stay with you long after you finish. Dive in.”—Daily Skimm
Anna Hart is a seasoned missing persons detective in San Francisco with far too much knowledge of the darkest side of human nature. When tragedy strikes her personal life, Anna, desperate and numb, flees to the Northern California village of Mendocino to grieve. She lived there as a child with her beloved foster parents, and now she believes it might be the only place left for her. Yet the day she arrives, she learns that a local teenage girl has gone missing.
The crime feels frighteningly reminiscent of the most crucial time in Anna’s childhood, when the unsolved murder of a young girl touched Mendocino and changed the community forever. As past and present collide, Anna realizes that she has been led to this moment. The most difficult lessons of her life have given her insight into how victims come into contact with violent predators. As Anna becomes obsessed with saving the missing girl, she must accept that true courage means getting out of her own way and learning to let others in.
Weaving together actual cases of missing persons, trauma theory, and a hint of the metaphysical, this propulsive and deeply affecting novel tells a story of fate, necessary redemption, and what it takes, when the worst happens, to reclaim our lives—and our faith in one another.
BUY THE BOOK
Community Reviews
What Bookclubbers are saying about this book
✨ Summarized by Bookclubs AI
Readers say *When the Stars Go Dark* is a gripping, raw, and emotional murder mystery with a true-crime feel and strong character depth. Many praise i...
This is a book unlike any I’ve read in a while. It is hard to categorize. It is unique. It is disturbing. It is hard to read in parts. It is raw. It is emotional. Don’t skip the acknowledgements or the author’s note. I highly recommend.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Paula McLain does a fantastic job mixing real life missing persons cases with this work of fiction that hits frighteningly close to reality.
I was invested in the story from the get-go and it gripped me through the very end.
There are mentions of abduction, murder, child neglect and sexual abuse but they are not explored in detail as to cause extreme discomfort.
If you like a great suspenseful mystery, then I definitely recommend When the Stars Go Dark.
Oh and did I mention; there's a dog and she's awesome.
Paula McLain does a fantastic job mixing real life missing persons cases with this work of fiction that hits frighteningly close to reality.
I was invested in the story from the get-go and it gripped me through the very end.
There are mentions of abduction, murder, child neglect and sexual abuse but they are not explored in detail as to cause extreme discomfort.
If you like a great suspenseful mystery, then I definitely recommend When the Stars Go Dark.
Oh and did I mention; there's a dog and she's awesome.
I’ve not been a big fan of McLain’s historical fiction, but figured I’d give her new mystery a chance. This one worked much better for me. I think it helped that Anna is totally fictional and McLain wasn’t trying to channel real people.
Anna is a detective that specializes in finding missing children. Something has happened in her personal life which has led to her separation from her husband. When she returns to her “home town” of Mendocino, she becomes involved in the case of a missing 15 year old. Anna was a well developed character. She had a traumatic childhood, losing her mother at an early age and growing up in foster care. She was, at least, blessed with great foster parents who gave her love and taught her a lot about nature and survival. In fact, the chapters that harken back to her time with her foster parents were some of the best. She is drawn to the missing girl, as she also had trauma in her early years.
The book has short chapters, which keeps the book moving at a brisk speed. The story takes place in 1993, and it was a bit of a shock to remember what it was like to manage without cellphones, Internet, DNA testing. I liked how McLain interweaves the actual abduction case of Polly Klass into the story. She also uses conversations between Anna and Will, the sheriff, to help the reader learn a lot about abductions, sexual abuse and trauma. This is a deeper than usual mystery.
I had no idea who was behind the abductions. McLain plotted out a believable ending with good old intuition leading to the bad guy.
Make sure to listen/read the Author’s Note, which truly surprised me.
Marin Ireland was the narrator and does her normal, great job.
Anna is a detective that specializes in finding missing children. Something has happened in her personal life which has led to her separation from her husband. When she returns to her “home town” of Mendocino, she becomes involved in the case of a missing 15 year old. Anna was a well developed character. She had a traumatic childhood, losing her mother at an early age and growing up in foster care. She was, at least, blessed with great foster parents who gave her love and taught her a lot about nature and survival. In fact, the chapters that harken back to her time with her foster parents were some of the best. She is drawn to the missing girl, as she also had trauma in her early years.
The book has short chapters, which keeps the book moving at a brisk speed. The story takes place in 1993, and it was a bit of a shock to remember what it was like to manage without cellphones, Internet, DNA testing. I liked how McLain interweaves the actual abduction case of Polly Klass into the story. She also uses conversations between Anna and Will, the sheriff, to help the reader learn a lot about abductions, sexual abuse and trauma. This is a deeper than usual mystery.
I had no idea who was behind the abductions. McLain plotted out a believable ending with good old intuition leading to the bad guy.
Make sure to listen/read the Author’s Note, which truly surprised me.
Marin Ireland was the narrator and does her normal, great job.
This is not the action-packed, fast-paced mystery/thriller story that I typically read. This is a truly psychological drama/mystery about a woman who is struggling with grief, the demise of her marriage, professional stress, as well as childhood issues (she’s a foster child) of abuse that had been buried and are now beginning to surface.
The story starts out with Anna escaping the tragedy and the subsequent fallout of the death of her child. While Anna makes reference to it frequently and a couple of associates offer condolences, the circumstances of the child’s death isn’t revealed until the end of the story. Anna, as well as her husband, blame her for the child’s death. Anna is forced to take a leave of absence from her position as a special agent with an agency in San Francisco that searches and finds missing children. Unfortunately, not all alive. She heads up north on the CA coast to Mendocino, her hometown, to hideout and grieve alone.
Upon getting to Mendocino, she discovers that a teenage girl has been missing for about 24hrs. The local Sheriff (Will), a childhood friend who she hasn’t seen since she left, is looking for the missing girl (Cameron) and agrees to let Anna help him search. The story starts in 1993 before the internet, social media, Amber Alerts and all of the high-tech CSI law enforcement systems we have now. The story flips back and forth between 1993 and 20yrs earlier when Anna was growing up in Mendocino, when another teenage girl went missing.
I LOVED that Anna and a stray dog find each other and rescue/adopt each other. Life if so much sweeter and less solitary with a fur baby and if anyone needs the comfort and companionship of a good doggy, it’s Anna. I know some readers will curse me for revealing this spoiler, but I also know that other readers will understand why I’ve done this – Cricket doesn’t die, she survives the stabbing.
I seriously did not know who the “killer” was and was surprised when it was revealed. I guess I was just so into the story of Anna (that I like very much) that maybe I wasn’t paying attention to all the details of the investigation to figure it out. I also liked seeing how Anna began to heal from her mental and emotional crisis. I also was moved by the author's notes at the end, they were both haunting and inspirational. Paula McLain is a good writer and I will definitely be checking out her other work.
The story starts out with Anna escaping the tragedy and the subsequent fallout of the death of her child. While Anna makes reference to it frequently and a couple of associates offer condolences, the circumstances of the child’s death isn’t revealed until the end of the story. Anna, as well as her husband, blame her for the child’s death. Anna is forced to take a leave of absence from her position as a special agent with an agency in San Francisco that searches and finds missing children. Unfortunately, not all alive. She heads up north on the CA coast to Mendocino, her hometown, to hideout and grieve alone.
Upon getting to Mendocino, she discovers that a teenage girl has been missing for about 24hrs. The local Sheriff (Will), a childhood friend who she hasn’t seen since she left, is looking for the missing girl (Cameron) and agrees to let Anna help him search. The story starts in 1993 before the internet, social media, Amber Alerts and all of the high-tech CSI law enforcement systems we have now. The story flips back and forth between 1993 and 20yrs earlier when Anna was growing up in Mendocino, when another teenage girl went missing.
I LOVED that Anna and a stray dog find each other and rescue/adopt each other. Life if so much sweeter and less solitary with a fur baby and if anyone needs the comfort and companionship of a good doggy, it’s Anna. I know some readers will curse me for revealing this spoiler, but I also know that other readers will understand why I’ve done this – Cricket doesn’t die, she survives the stabbing.
I seriously did not know who the “killer” was and was surprised when it was revealed. I guess I was just so into the story of Anna (that I like very much) that maybe I wasn’t paying attention to all the details of the investigation to figure it out. I also liked seeing how Anna began to heal from her mental and emotional crisis. I also was moved by the author's notes at the end, they were both haunting and inspirational. Paula McLain is a good writer and I will definitely be checking out her other work.
I am an outlier on this one based on all the other reviews. I don't understand all the high ratings. I don't necessarily shy away from dark reads (this is very dark, serial violent offenders, sexual abuse) but it was also so slow. Anna is a missing persons detective detective who flees to Northern California to take a break from her job and marriage when tragedy strikes her own life. However, a local girl, Cameron, has gone missing and Anna finds herself working another case. There were too many characters and I just wasn't all that interested in any of them. I was curious about what happened to Cameron and Anna. I didn't care for the real life story of Polly Klaas intertwined with the fictional story of the local missing girls. It was distracting and didn't add to the story for me.