This Is How It Always Is: A Novel

By Laurie Frankel

New York Times Bestseller The Reese Witherspoon x Hello Sunshine Book Club Pick People Magazine’s Top 10 Books of the year The Globe and Mail's Top 100 Books of the year “It made me laugh, it made me cry, it made me think.” —Liane Moriarty, #1 New York Times bestselling author of Big Little Lies This is how a family keeps a secret . . . and how that secret ends up keeping them. This is how a family lives happily ever after . . . until happily ever after becomes complicated. This is how children change . . . and then change the world. This is Claude. He’s five years old, the youngest of five brothers, and loves peanut butter sandwiches. He also loves wearing a dress, and dreams of being a princess. When he grows up, Claude says, he wants to be a girl. Rosie and Penn want Claude to be whoever Claude wants to be. They’re just not sure they’re ready to share that with the world. Soon the entire family is keeping Claude’s secret. Until one day it explodes. Laurie Frankel's This Is How It Always Is is a novel about revelations, transformations, fairy tales, and family. And it’s about the ways in which this is how it always is: Change is always hard and miraculous and hard again, parenting is always a leap into the unknown with crossed fingers and full hearts, children grow but not always according to plan. And families with secrets don’t get to keep them forever.

BUY THE BOOK

Published Jan 23, 2018

336 pages

Average rating: 7.98

742 RATINGS

|

|

BOOK TALK

Community Reviews

What Bookclubbers are saying about this book

✨ Summarized by Bookclubs AI

Readers say *This Is How It Always Is* is a deeply moving, tender family story about love, acceptance, and parenting through a young child’s transgend...

Sue
8/10 stars
I don't want to give any hints as to what this book is about. Don't read about it first, don't read the blurb on the dust jacket. Don't read a recap. Just read it, as I was told to do. You won't regret it.
Liz
8/10 stars

This was a book club selection and to be honest, I hadn’t bothered reading a description of the book. So, I was initially thrown by the story and wasn’t sure where this book was going. Rosie and Penn are the parents of 5 young boys. Their household is as crazy as you would imagine. It takes awhile before we learn that the youngest, Claude, five years old, likes to wear a dress and wants to grow up to be a girl. The parents and siblings, even his grandmother, are super accepting. But what about the rest of the world? And when the parents fall into a decision not to tell, have they truly thought out the future ramifications?

The book tackles the whole situation with a mix of humor and pathos. I loved that in the beginning, their world is so chaotic with five children that Claude’s desire to wear a dress doesn’t even rise to the top of the priority list.

The book makes you think with each turn of the page. What should one family member be willing to give up for another? What should a parent do in this situation? Is it ok to “play favorites” when children have different needs? And I totally got how what seems like the perfect choice in one year comes back to bite you in the rear later on.

I’ve always had a fascination with Buddhism, so I loved how Frankel incorporated it into this book.

The entire time I was reading this, I wondered what inspired Frankel. Well, let’s just say she knows of what she writes. Make sure to read the Author’s Note.

I’m reading this for my book club and it’s a perfect choice.

Medilsom
6/10 stars
This story is a deeply moving novel about a family navigating the journey of raising a transgender child. The story follows Claude, who has always known she is a girl and renames herself Poppy after her mother's late sister. The book brilliantly captures the tension of protecting a child from outside cruelty and misunderstanding while fostering a safe space for self-expression at home. Especially touching are the imaginative bedtime stories Poppy’s father, Penn, uses to help her make sense of the world. As a parent, it is easy to connect with the universal fears of navigating unfamiliar territory and the constant worry of making mistakes while trying to do right by your child. Ultimately, this is a tender, thought-provoking story about the fear of the unknown, self-discovery, and the profound strength of a family learning to support one another.
wonderedpages
6/10 stars
Book club put This Is How It Always Is in my hands. My feelings landed right in the middle. Laurie Frankel writes a tender family story about Rosie and Penn, parents of five children, as their youngest biologically male child begins telling them she wants to live as a girl. The family names her Poppy, surrounds her with love, and tries to protect her from a world that is often cruel to people it refuses to understand. My biggest struggle was the writing. The novel often spells out its message so directly that the story starts to feel instructed rather than discovered. I sometimes felt like I was reading a list of every painful thing a trans child and her parents might experience, instead of watching those moments unfold through natural storytelling. The subject matter is important, but the delivery felt too on the nose at times. Penn’s fairy tale book was one of my favorite threads. It was sweet, whimsical, and full of the warmth I wanted more consistently from the larger story. Its placement occasionally interrupted the flow, but the idea itself was adorable. The Walsh-Adams family is easily lovable. Rosie and Penn are imperfect, loving, and fiercely protective parents who try to build a safer world for their daughter before the world is ready to offer her one. Their children are kind, accepting, and tender with each other. The people who bully, judge, and discriminate against Poppy are awful. The book makes one thing very clear. A lack of understanding never gives anyone permission to be hateful. This Is How It Always Is did not completely work for me as a novel, but I appreciated its compassion, family dynamics, and belief that love should lead people toward action. Pick this up if you enjoy emotional family fiction, parenting stories, and books about identity, secrecy, and acceptance. It is a thoughtful choice for readers who appreciate stories about families choosing love again and again.
spoko
6/10 stars
I’m not sure this book knows what it wants to be. It’s written like a YA book, so you’d tend to think that it’s a book about a trans kid beginning to discover and express their identity. But on the other hand, it doesn’t really seem to be about Poppy—it seemed to be more about her parents. In the end, I think it’s a book about parenting a trans kid, more than about being a trans kid. But it is certainly written with the depth and complexity of a not-very-challenging YA book. The characters, relationships, conversations and situations all have a very didactic quality to them. Everyone is playing a type, and every plot point is serving a purpose. This isn’t to say that no moments have any real impact—the scene when Poppy calls her mom to tell her that everyone knows is one example that I thought landed powerfully. But it’s also one of the few instances when the writing has real restraint; I wish such instances were more significant and/or more frequent. In the end, there was very little that I disagreed with, and from a human level I was able to empathize with these parents and their decisions (even the passive ones, that often had so much impact). But I just never really felt engaged. Once you get The Lesson of the book, there’s not much else for you.