Things We Cannot Keep: Contemporary Southern Literary Fiction for Book Clubs with Family Secrets and Redemption

By Amanda Cox

A mysterious package. A name she thought she'd erased. And the one person she never expected to see again. Tess Holcomb has built a new life in Alabama, repairing timepieces and avoiding her troubled past as she restores her customers' family heirlooms--treasures she never had. When a mysterious package arrives addressed to Teresa Baker, the name she abandoned, Tess finds herself drawn into a puzzle that threatens her delicate peace. Then Elliot Sullivan appears at her door after eighteen years, and Tess knows he's after more than just forgiveness. She doesn't trust his motives, but he could be the key to uncovering the origin of the mystery package and its cryptic contents. Tess has found safety in her simple life, but to reunite this lost heirloom with its rightful recipient she will have to come out of hiding. Each clue leads her further from the security of home, and each story reveals hidden truths. The question is whether she's brave enough to face what she might find--and whether the man beside her can be trusted with what matters most. Award-winning author Amanda Cox crafts an intercontinental journey of connection, healing, love, community, and belonging perfect for book clubs, fans of Southern fiction, and readers of T. I. Lowe, Charles Martin, Sara Brunsvold, and Valerie Fraser Luesse.

BUY THE BOOK

Published Aug 18, 2026

336 pages

Average rating: 10

1 RATING

|

|

BOOK TALK

Community Reviews

jenlynerickson
jenlynerickson
10/10 stars
“Teresa Baker was born into a world in which safety and security were unattainable commodities. But despite the odds stacked against her, she was a fighter with a spirit not easily snuffed out. The day she turned eighteen, she was forced to flee the only home she’d ever known, taking with her little more than the clothes on her back and a souvenir magnet depicting a place she’d only known through her grandmother’s memories. And with that borrowed hope, she set out to make a new life. A better life. Through the kindness of a couple strangers, Tess was able to find the family she’d always craved with good people who put her first. And she built a business from the ground up that inspires people to dust off their old family heirlooms and celebrate the legacies they represent.” But when a mysterious watch arrives at her door addressed to her previous identity, the precarious lives of Teresa Baker and Tess Holcomb collide. “She was entering a fairy world. Apparently, this particular fairy world was a backward realm in which she banded together with her nemesis to solve the mystery of an antique pocket watch…The watch had traveled from the Netherlands, to Germany, back to the Netherlands, on to New York, and now Bowling Green…A mere two hours from the hometown from which she has been running. Tess never asked for any of this. Not the mystery watch. Not a renewed connection with a complicated ex. Not a trip around the world. Things We Cannot Keep is “The story of reuniting a long-lost pocket watch that’s impacted countless lives during a harrowing time in history with the family it originally belonged to. Learning how it’s traveled thousands and thousands of miles. Lived multiple lives.” The story behind the clock and the path it traveled “might be simple and sweet. But despite appearances, life and its accompanying memories were more layered and nuanced than they often appeared. A story doesn’t need to be pain-free to be beautiful.” Tess loves hearing other people’s beautiful family histories, but sometimes she’s so focused on the past that she misses the one beautiful life she’s been given. Things We Cannot Keep is a reminder to chase your own story every now and then. Because you matter. And even in the darkest places, you aren’t ever truly alone. No matter how much time is lost, God can restore. Amanda Cox’s latest novel is timeless, a precious story meant to keep!

See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.