The Wishing Game: A Novel

This may be my favorite standalone book I’ve read all year. First of all, Clock Island is magical. The writing transports you right there, and I was sad when the book was over and I had to leave.

My favorite character was Jack, he felt like the picture of altruism, compassion and warmth.

I did not find any of the storylines problematic like many other readers did. The relationship between Lucy and Christopher did not feel creepy at all. She wasn’t secretly pining for this child, she even meets with his adoption caseworker. There were no ill intentions there. Maybe a bit of an unrealistic fantasy, but other than that, as a former educator, I related very much to Lucy wanting to save a child from their difficult home life.

The ending had me sobbing happy tears.

This book made me feel, deeply. I feel that this has the potential to be a series and I hope there will someday be a book two.

Loved this one. Made me nostalgic for the books that got me reading when I was a kid.

It was fine. I liked the premise, and I can definitely see why people love this one, especially the whole love letter to books and childhood stories. There were some genuinely sweet moments, and I liked the idea of Clock Island and the contest. But... I just didn't love it. It was enjoyable enough, but I never really found myself getting invested in it the way I wanted to.

No regrets reading it, but I don't think this is going to be one I think about for very long.

Lonely children making wishes and sending to a beloved author to grant.

This book really brings childhood reads to life. The author does a good job with making the story, places, and characters feel real.