The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic: A Novel

This is a really charming and feel good story. I loved the small town mixed with magic, making it the perfect read for October. I enjoyed the romantic aspects eventhough that wasn’t the main focus of the story it made for more depth in Sadie’s character and had some really cute moments. I don’t know if there will be a sequel but I would love to know what happens next in Poppy Meadows!

The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic implied a story about cozy witchcraft, family bonds, romance, and recipes. I expected the warm charm advertised in the blurb with comparisons to Practical Magic and Gilmore Girls. This family was so dysfunctional that I spent more time questioning everyone’s decisions than enjoying the magic. Sadie Revelare built her life around protecting her magical gifts. Four heartbreaks will cost her that magic and she has already survived three. Her grandmother Gigi’s terminal diagnosis, her estranged twin brother’s return, and the reappearance of her first love Jake quickly dismantles the structured life she has created. These upheavals also expose generations of Revelare family secrets. The family revelations destroyed much of the cozy atmosphere. Gigi withholds vital information, magically exiles her daughter after an unwanted pregnancy, asks family members to kill people, requests her own murder, and admits responsibility for the death of Sadie and Seth’s father. The family treats these revelations with a level of acceptance that baffled me. Gigi stopped being an eccentric grandmother and became the villain of the Revelare family history. The magic system added more confusion for me. Sadie infuses food with magical intentions which I think was supposed to be charming. The constant on the nose explanations of what individual ingredients supposedly accomplish became repetitive instead. Recipes and ingredient properties take up so much attention that parts of the novel read more like a magical food blog than a fantasy romance. The romance did little to rescue the book. Several relationship choices made the characters unlikeable. The storyline involving a man cheating on his pregnant fiancée was terrible. A bizarre stolen dog situation was surprisingly of little concern from the people involved. I felt that too many conflicts depended on characters withholding information, accepting harmful behavior, or making decisions that create problems nobody needed. Pick this up if you want to spend time in Poppy Meadows exploring food centered cozy fantasy, family drama, and magical recipes. I wanted stronger magical worldbuilding, relationships worth cheering for, and consequences that matched the seriousness of the family’s actions. The Unfortunate Side Effects of Heartbreak and Magic never had ingredients that came together into a recipe I wanted to cook up twice.

I absolutely loved it. When it comes to magic and love genre, this is by far one of my favorites. Perfect for fans of books/movies like Practical Magic.

It was okay. It's touted as Gilmore Girls meets Practical Magic... I felt the Practical Magic vibes, not so much Gilmore Girls which sucks cause thats my all time favorite show. The premise was unique. There some punctuation and other small errors that I know aren't big in the grand scheme of things but they do take me out of the story. Overall I'd say it was good but I don't know if I'd read it again.

What a fun book! I didn’t expect much due to other reviews, but I’m glad I paid them no mind. The magical details and recipes brought so much life. “River water is for moving on and sea water is for healing. Storm water is for strengthening, or if you’re feeling ambitious, cures. Water that falls as lightning strikes will cause disaster sure as a cracked mirror or walking under a ladder.” Book #24 in 2024