The Personal Librarian: A GMA Book Club Pick

Fascinating story about an African-American woman who was librarian to Pierpont Morgan’s library. The stress of her passing, was clear on just about every page. I liked the story, I liked the characters, but I could always tell they were writing a book. I had hoped for a little more depth in the character.

Very well written and extraordinary true story in historical fiction style. Has many topics for bookclub discussion. Highly recommend.

Great historical fiction. Can't believe it was based on a true story. Very timely.

The Personal Librarian left me with many things to ponder. Especially, the thought of what it was like to be a light colored Black woman in the early 1900’s. Benedict and Murray really dug into some tough race and gender issues. I had never heard of Belle da Costa Greene, but Benedict and Murray did a beautiful job of imagining her life and struggles. The notes from each author at the end were so touching. I think the fact that Marie Benedict sought out Victoria Christopher Murray to add her Black perspective to this story was so thoughtful. It sets the example of partnering with those who have more expertise in certain human experiences.

There were some sections where the story line dragged. I also was a bit off-put by the very Eurocentric focus of the literature and art frequently mentioned, but it was J.P. Morgan's collections - so what else should I have expected. The authors do a good job of explaining why works such as those printed by William Caxton would be a featured highlight of the library. Before reading, I thought I might be rensentful of the protagonist and her "deception". As a Black American, I can't imagine existing and watching others of my same ethnicity suffer. However, the decision was so much more nuanced than my modern perspective could imagine. Ultimately I left the book intrigued by this woman and the impact she had on her contemporaries and those who came after her.