The House in the Orchard

By Elizabeth Brooks

CrimeReads Best Gothic Fiction of 2022 A BuzzFeed, Good Housekeeping, and Departures Magazine Best Book of Fall A startling gothic tale of corrupted innocence that asks—when we look closely—what it really means to know the truth. When a World War II widow inherits a dilapidated English estate, she uncovers a diary written by an adolescent girl named Maude Gower. Looking for answers, she begins reading, only to unravel more questions about the mysterious past and many secrets hidden deep within the walls of Orchard House. In 1876, orphaned Maude is forced to leave London, and her adored brother, Frank, to live with a stranger. Everyone—especially Frank—tells her not to trust Miss Greenaway, the enigmatic owner of Orchard House, but Maude can’t help warming to her new guardian. Encouraged by Miss Greenaway, Maude finds herself discovering who she is for the first time, and learning to love her new home. But when Frank comes for an unexpected visit, the delicate balance of Maude’s life is thrown into disarray. Complicating matters more, Maude witnesses an adult world full of interactions she cannot quite understand. Her efforts to regain control result in a violent tragedy, the repercussions of which will haunt Orchard House for the rest of Maude’s life—and beyond. With each psychologically gripping turn, Elizabeth Brooks masterfully explores the blurred lines between truth and manipulation, asking us who we can trust, how to tell guilt from forgiveness, and whether we can ever really separate true love from destruction.

BUY THE BOOK

Published Sep 27, 2022

320 pages

Average rating: 7.5

6 RATINGS

|

|

BOOK TALK

Community Reviews

AngeCIOM
8/10 stars
CRANKY'S BOOK CLUB REVIEW OF THE HOUSE IN THE ORCHARD, WITH INPUT FROM THE AUTHOR HERSELF, ELIZABETH BROOKS Tonight's book group was rather special in that the author herself had come along to hear our views on her novel. Luckily, we had all enjoyed it! The novel slips between a diary of an orphaned middle-class Victorian girl called Maude, and a time around fifty years later, at the end of WWII, when Peggy, the widowed wife of Maude's nephew, takes up residence in the house that Maude had been bequeathed to her late husband. On the surface, the book is an engrossing, frequently funny read. Maude's character is frequently quite shocking in her spiteful opinions and calculated revenges, but she is also engaging and amusing, and most of us felt that it was easy to feel sorry for her, given her circumstances. The diary felt to many like a very believable safe place where a bright but bored young teenager has let off a lot of steam – or, to others, a place where a contrary, conniving and dangerous person has tried, unsuccessfully, to conceal her true colours. Under that surface, the book has a whole array of mysteries that only really come to light at the very end of the book. Frank deals what could be a fatal blow to Maude's account, claiming that she wrote it years later and that it was all an attempt by the adult Maude to whitewash her reputation. Most of us didn't see this coming. A lot of us found ourselves returning to earlier parts of the book to revisit scenes as the plot twisted, especially at the start of a time shift when they had been engrossed in the diary. We talked about the extent to which we believed that Maude was an unreliable author. Some of us believed Frank's argument that Maude had written the diary as an adult and planted it to exonerate herself from murder. Others in the group point to how controlling and manipulative Frank had been, throughout the novel and we agreed that while Maude was definitely writing for an audience, the extent to which she was lying remains a mystery. Setting Maude’s crime aside, it was Victorian prudery and convention that proved to be the real villain of this book. Elizabeth agreed that it could be seen to be a feminist response to the highly sexist Victorian novels she’d read, and we as readers found it satisfying to have female characters allowed to have educations and lovers without being framed as weird or villainous by the author for doing so. Saying that, some of the chances that the female characters had were difficult to believe – would Emily really have had a chance to study at university, given her low social status and lack of financial means? For some, Kitty and Maude felt like characters from a more modern age – which could bolster Frank's argument that Maude wrote the diary as an adult. The ending of the book really divided us as a group. Some of us were annoyed by its open-endedness, whereas others felt it was a satisfyingly natural and subtle ending to the story. Elizabeth told us that she had tried alternative endings, including one where Peggy’s husband hadn’t died and had returned at the end of the story, but that this had felt too sweet and contrived. We all enjoyed this novel and were surprised that the book only had a US release at present. We asked Elizabeth what her thoughts were on this. Interestingly, it turns out that for authors relatively early in their published careers, it’s the smaller publishing houses that are more able to nurture and develop them – the large houses with their hundreds of authors are less inclined to do so, because they are crowded markets. How interesting and paradoxical - aspiring authors should take note and aim for the indie houses with good reputations rather than the giants!