The Familiar Dark

By Amy Engel

BUY THE BOOK

245 pages

Average rating: 7.33

3 RATINGS

|

|

BOOK TALK

Community Reviews

JHSiess
8/10 stars
In her second novel geared toward adult audiences, author Amy Engel turns her attention to an exploration of "the shadowy side of the human experience." The Familiar Dark is an atmospheric, uncompromisingly disturbing study of the way a woman whose only child is brutally murdered reacts to her loss.

Eve and her brother, Cal, were raised in squalor by an abusive, drug-addicted mother with a succession of unsavory boyfriends. She physically punished her children for infractions such as crying because they were hungry, telling them, "You had it coming," a phrase that came to be thought of by her children as her manta expressing her philosophy about life. The two of them clung to each other, vowing that they would escape their circumstances and make better lives for themselves. Cal became a police officer and, although plenty of women find him attractive, has never settled down. Eve became pregnant before her senior year in high school, but there was never any question about whether she would keep the baby. That's just what women in their family always do.

In response to motherhood, Eve changed. She quit drinking, smoking, and getting in trouble. She gave up men. Well, except for Jimmy Ray. And ultimately, she did what was required to extricate herself from that abusive relationship. She continued working as a waitress at the diner, and Junie's needs have always been her priority. Motherhood isn't easy, of course, but unlike her own mother, Eve has been an affectionate, supportive, and caring mother, despite lacking the financial means to give Junie everything she wants and deserves. Junie's presence made Eve's life bearable. To ensure that Junie would not be adversely influenced, Eve cut all ties with her mother.

Cal has always been a doting uncle. And to Eve's surprise, Junie developed a strong bond and tight friendship with a girl her age, Izzy Logan, the daughter of Jenny and Zach. Jenny went away to college, but opted to return with her husband, Zach, who is in line to take over her father's boat dealership, to raise their daughter in Barron Springs. The Logans' affluence was never a barrier to the girls' relationship.

Despite all her efforts, Eve has carried a sense of dread and foreboding, worry that something horrible would happen to Junie. As the story opens, Junie is expected home after spending the night at Izzy's house. Instead, Cal arrives at the diner to inform Eve that the girls' bodies have been discovered in the local park, their throats slit. That was never the horror story Eve envisioned.

Engel examines the lessons Eve learned growing up via her first-person narrative detailing the aftermath of the murders. The police insist they are investigating the crime and seek Eve's cooperation. But they ask too much. Eve needs to know who is responsible for her daughter's death and why she was killed. As the days pass, her frustration grows and Engel gradually reveals how deeply the lessons of childhood are ingrained in Eve as, little by little, she descends into the depths of her psyche where the feral approach to life she learned from her mother and sought for so many years to rise above still resides. Eve relates her journey back to the places and people she left behind, including her mother and that horrid trailer deep in the Missouri woods. For all her faults, Eve knows that her mother loves her in her own way. And just as Eve is about to give up on her yet again, her mother "reach[es] out with a tender hand." Her advice unleashes a ferocious power that has always existed within Eve.

Would Eve have summoned that strength, even without encouragement from her mother? Engel challenges readers to ponder that and many other questions as Eve presses for the truth. As she stealthily follows every clue, Engel ramps up the tension and pace. And with each clue, Eve slips a little further not just back into the life from which she extricated herself, but back into her old self. One by one, she abandons her self-imposed reforms. She has her first drink in years, accepts a cigarette from her mother, and pays visits to the strip club Jimmy Ray owns, as well as his compound, all in the name of learning the identity of her child's murderer and the motive for her killing.

The Familiar Dark is an absorbing look at small-town America -- it's ugliness and beauty. It's an intricate and remarkable tale about how secrets and betrayals can harm innocents. It's a commentary on the fierceness of motherhood, and a provocative exploration of the lengths to which Eve will go to extract justice for her slain daughter. Engel reveals details about Eve's past, including Junie's parentage, at expertly-plotted intervals that provide context while moving the action forward.

Eve's story is compelling and haunting, especially because it is related from her perspective. She is extremely intelligent and highly self-aware. Propelled by anger, she understands, on a visceral level, each step that brings her closer to the truth -- why she is taking it, the potential ramifications, what it means to her and, perhaps, most importantly, what her willingness to take that step says about her values and her future. Eve is "at home in the dark" and has reconciled herself to the fact that she will never forgive herself unless she sees her quest for justice "through to the end." And the end is powerful, tragic, unambiguous and, potentially, controversial. The Familiar Dark is an engrossing, nuanced story.

Thanks to NetGalley for an Advance Reader's Copy of the book.