The Death Row Club

A dark, dazzlingly original psychological thriller about a woman invited to an annual weekend getaway for the adult children of serial killers...but when one of the participants ends up dead, they begin to wonder if someone among them might be carrying on the family traditions.
When Nicola Fischer’s father is arrested for the murder of five women—including her best friend—the entire world watches it unfold on To Catch a Killer, the hit true crime TV show hosted by Greer Woods. Overnight, Nicola becomes a pariah: fired from her job, drowning in debt, and shunned by everyone she knows. And to make matters worse, Greer—once a budding friend and fellow child of a serial killer—hasn’t returned a single call since the show aired.
Then comes an unexpected invitation to the Death Row Club, a secret retreat for the adult children of serial killers—founded by none other than Greer herself. Desperate for answers and human connection, Nicola agrees to go. At first, it seems like exactly what she needs. The club members are strange but welcoming, and Greer seems eager to mend their fractured friendship.
But when a mysterious girl arrives, claiming her father is a killer too, the club’s fragile peace is shattered, unraveling the buried secrets at its core. By morning, the girl has vanished. By afternoon, one of the club members is dead.
Now everyone is watching Nicola. After all, she’s the daughter of a monster. And monsters raise monsters...don’t they?
BUY THE BOOK
Community Reviews
The Death Row Club had me excited from the title alone. Adult children of serial killers trapped at a remote retreat while someone starts picking them off? Sign me up. Unfortunately, the execution never lived up to the premise.

First, can we talk about the teacher slander? I somehow managed to suspend my disbelief when Nicola was fired after 15 years of teaching because of parent complaints—with no evidence, no due process, and apparently no employment laws. That’s… not how any of that works. But okay. I accepted it because, obviously, the plot needed her to hit rock bottom.
Then came the part implying she became an art teacher because she couldn’t make it as an artist. Excuse me while I clutch my librarian badge. As if teaching is some consolation prize you stumble into after your dreams don’t pan out. That’s an insult to every educator who intentionally chose the profession.
And the title? Misleading. The Death Row Club sounds like everyone shares the same connection, but only two members actually have parents on death row. The rest? Different circumstances entirely. That’s less “Death Row Club” and more “People With Deeply Problematic Family Histories Club.”
The biggest disappointment, though, was the mystery itself. The twists didn’t feel earned so much as… manufactured. The story bounces around in time without making it remotely clear you’re reading flashbacks. I spent most of the book assuming I was confused, only to discover near the end that the timeline had been playing hide-and-seek the whole time. That’s not a twist—that’s withholding basic directions.
If your biggest plot twist is making me realize I’ve been reading the past for half the book… we have problems.
As for the big reveal… explaining it would spoil the book, but let’s just say the identity backstory gymnastics had me staring at the page like, “Well… that’s certainly a choice.” Needless to say, I thought it was completely ridiculous.
This had all the ingredients for a deliciously creepy thriller, but somehow managed to turn them into the literary equivalent of trail mix without the chocolate.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Gallery Books for this review copy.

First, can we talk about the teacher slander? I somehow managed to suspend my disbelief when Nicola was fired after 15 years of teaching because of parent complaints—with no evidence, no due process, and apparently no employment laws. That’s… not how any of that works. But okay. I accepted it because, obviously, the plot needed her to hit rock bottom.
Then came the part implying she became an art teacher because she couldn’t make it as an artist. Excuse me while I clutch my librarian badge. As if teaching is some consolation prize you stumble into after your dreams don’t pan out. That’s an insult to every educator who intentionally chose the profession.
And the title? Misleading. The Death Row Club sounds like everyone shares the same connection, but only two members actually have parents on death row. The rest? Different circumstances entirely. That’s less “Death Row Club” and more “People With Deeply Problematic Family Histories Club.”
The biggest disappointment, though, was the mystery itself. The twists didn’t feel earned so much as… manufactured. The story bounces around in time without making it remotely clear you’re reading flashbacks. I spent most of the book assuming I was confused, only to discover near the end that the timeline had been playing hide-and-seek the whole time. That’s not a twist—that’s withholding basic directions.
If your biggest plot twist is making me realize I’ve been reading the past for half the book… we have problems.
As for the big reveal… explaining it would spoil the book, but let’s just say the identity backstory gymnastics had me staring at the page like, “Well… that’s certainly a choice.” Needless to say, I thought it was completely ridiculous.
This had all the ingredients for a deliciously creepy thriller, but somehow managed to turn them into the literary equivalent of trail mix without the chocolate.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Gallery Books for this review copy.
Whoa, what a ride.
There is no doubt in my mind that The Death Row Club will live in my head rent-free.
This is the kind of thriller you don't simply finish. You sit with it. You replay it. You question it. As someone who reads a lot of thrillers every year, I pride myself on spotting twists before they happen. This book humbled me. Every theory I came up with was completely wrong, and I loved every minute of it.
Told through the perspectives of two characters, the novel explores a fascinating question: What happens to the families of serial killers?
The victims' stories are often told, and rightly so, but we rarely stop to consider the lives of those who share a last name with the person responsible. Their careers, friendships, relationships, and identities become permanently intertwined with crimes they never committed. They aren't guilty, yet they often find themselves serving a different kind of life sentence.
That premise alone was enough to hook me.
Then comes the Death Row Club, a place where people connected by this unimaginable experience can find understanding, community, and a brief escape from the judgment of the outside world. Naturally, that sense of safety doesn't last for long, and once the story begins unraveling, so do all of your assumptions. At one point, I was questioning absolutely everything. Honestly, I think I even started distrusting the woods.
Beyond the suspense, what stayed with me most were the moral and ethical questions the novel raises. How much of another person's actions should define your life? Can society ever separate someone from the crimes committed by a family member? Those are the conversations that linger long after the mystery is solved.
This would make an outstanding book club selection because everyone will walk away with a different perspective, and I suspect the discussions would be just as memorable as the story itself.
If you enjoy twisty thrillers that challenge both your theories and your conscience, I cannot recommend this one enough.
Thank you, NetGalley, V.A. Vazquez, and Gallery Books for the ARC. All comments and opinions are my own.
First physical book ive read in years. Read it in one day. Was pretty good👍