Loonshots: How to Nurture the Crazy Ideas That Win Wars, Cure Diseases, and Transform Industries

By Safi Bahcall

* Instant WSJ bestseller * Translated into 18 languages * #1 Most Recommended Book of the year (Bloomberg annual survey of CEOs and entrepreneurs) * An Amazon, Bloomberg, Financial Times, Forbes, Inc., Newsweek, Strategy + Business, Tech Crunch, Washington Post Best Business Book of the year * Recommended by Bill Gates, Daniel Kahneman, Malcolm Gladwell, Dan Pink, Adam Grant, Susan Cain, Sid Mukherjee, Tim Ferriss Why do good teams kill great ideas? Loonshots reveals a surprising new way of thinking about the mysteries of group behavior that challenges everything we thought we knew about nurturing radical breakthroughs. Bahcall, a physicist and entrepreneur, shows why teams, companies, or any group with a mission will suddenly change from embracing new ideas to rejecting them, just as flowing water will suddenly change into brittle ice. Mountains of print have been written about culture. Loonshots identifies the small shifts in structure that control this transition, the same way that temperature controls the change from water to ice. Using examples that range from the spread of fires in forests to the hunt for terrorists online, and stories of thieves and geniuses and kings, Bahcall shows how a new kind of science can help us become the initiators, rather than the victims, of innovative surprise. Over the past decade, researchers have been applying the tools and techniques of this new science—the science of phase transitions—to understand how birds flock, fish swim, brains work, people vote, diseases erupt, and ecosystems collapse. Loonshots is the first to apply this science to the spread of breakthrough ideas. Bahcall distills these insights into practical lessons creatives, entrepreneurs, and visionaries can use to change our world. Along the way, readers will learn how chickens saved millions of lives, what James Bond and Lipitor have in common, what the movie Imitation Game got wrong about WWII, and what really killed Pan Am, Polaroid, and the Qing Dynasty. “If The Da Vinci Code and Freakonomics had a child together, it would be called Loonshots.” —Senator Bob Kerrey

BUY THE BOOK

Published Mar 19, 2019

368 pages

Average rating: 7

2 RATINGS

|

|

BOOK TALK

Community Reviews

Jurij
6/10 stars
1. HOW LOONSHOTS WON A War 17
9/10

First chapter takes us into WW2 USA radar development and how Vannevar Bush kickstarted the creative inventing era for the military and made radar and the Manhattan Project. Top chapter. I do feel it's a tad short for the topic at hand. It feels like a short 1 hour audiobook overview and I would have liked waaaay more info. But this is a perfect chapter for such a book. The military R&D was outdated and ran top-down and then remade during the war to make USA able to win it. They should have done this before the war to not lose millions of lives and equipment. The rader system alone decimated the German U-boats. Something that would have made USA overpower Germany early on if this system worked initially. Which is a shame as the author explains that the radar tools and ideas were there already. But with the top-down system you can't try out weird stuff or implement small ideas. A technology is not functioning before you invest a ton of money and hours into it. So it's never quite worth it initially and therefore you need a bottom-up system to push this through initially then a top-down system to market it.

2. THE SURPRISING FRAGILITY OF THE LOONSHOT 45
7/10

About research into cancer etc. I already reviewed it. Not sure why my text didn't save. But the chapter is a bit all over the place and biased. Still fun enough.

3. THE TWO TYPES OF LOONSHOTS: TRIPPE VS. CRANDALL 65
7/10

Largely about PanAm. Pretty engaging, but feels like a summary. We get into Charles Lindbergh, WW2, Boeing. But each such topic needs a book in itself. And PanAm for sure needs a full book, but the chapter is a great intro. I'm just not sure he proved his case. The examples are so rushed that I'm not sure any reader can agree with him on even basic facts. Why did PanAm go bankrupt? Unless you present this over 10 pages no one will just believe it and here it's presented in basically a few sentences. This makes his argument a bit weak. But how PanAm became big is explained well and in detail.

4. EDWIN LAND AND THE MOSES TRAP 94
7/10

Canon dominates the photo camera market by inventing new technology. Yet when digital cameras arrive they refuse to release them as it would take away from the film market. I am over this book by now as it's too many small stories.

5. ESCAPING THE MOSES TRAP 121
6/10

Top-down leadership and how you need a bunch of money and buyers to create the product.

6. PHASE TRANSITIONS, I: MARRIAGE, FOREST FIRES, AND TERRORISTS 160
6/10

About systems and how you can use systems to create products.

7. PHASE TRANSITIONS, II: THE MAGIC NUMBER 150 186
6/10

He recommends keeping the groups small with flat leadership to keep creativity going.

8. THE FOURTH RULE 203
6/10

He recommends paying everyone fairly to keep workers.

9. WHY THE WORLD SPEAKS ENGLISH 231
6/10

In the book he explores how India or China could have been the leaders of the world, but instead demolished their creative and outspreading groups.

Book review/b>

I like how it starts and overall I think the idea is strong. But frankly it overstays its welcome by many hours as an audiobook. I don't really get the loonshot idea and don't really think the author gets it either. It's kinda a loose excuse to write a book which is fine and cool, but I feel like the idea is not fully explored or explained as to me it just sounds like another word for creativity. Which would actually make for a better topic and book. Loonshot is a nonsense word just describing a new product and idea that becomes huge. So yeah, creativity and money creates this and that's what you need and he recommends. He also describes this process so why not focus on the process instead of this hollow idea about nothing concrete? He is making everything more dull and more complex by trying to constantly reinvent the wheel of simple ideas.

I think the book is great if you own your own company and develop new products regularly. I could imagine business owners would rate this highly as it can inspire them. But to me it's just not focused enough. It feels like 100 stories one after another with a too loose connection. And after 20 stories you become really tired of it. It never gets bad. I just felt like it lost focus as he himself didn't really have a structure here.

Honestly why create all these new terms? You probably assume the chapters about Moses trap are about some amazing new idea in the business literature? Nope, it just means "blind top down leadership". That's it. The idea is thousands years old and described in any psychology and business book. Are you trying to rebrand it or sound smart by using new terms? I already forgot most of the book because the author insists on these weird roundabout explanations and ideas that make simple stuff more complex for no good reason.

Obviously this guy is a very talented writer and smart as heck. I would gladly read any book he wrote on a single topic. But once he starts being creative and expand the stories it becomes messy. It reads like a textbook. I can't really recommend it. But on the other hand I do think it's quality writing and the study behind the book is great too.