Community Reviews
*3.5/5*
Julie Olivia’s If It Makes You Happy is a cozy, low-stakes romance that feels like a warm hug for fans of Gilmore Girls and 1997 nostalgia. The autumn atmosphere and Vermont B&B setting are immaculate, providing the perfect backdrop for Cliff, a quintessential "cinnamon roll" single dad who carries the emotional weight of the story. However, the pacing is a true slow burn that occasionally feels more like a crawl, with repetitive banter delaying the romantic payoff until the final act. While the exploration of grief and eldest daughter syndrome is touching, Michelle’s constant internal spiraling and neuroticism can become exhausting for the reader. It is a sweet, comforting read that perfectly captures a specific 90s aesthetic, even if the plot occasionally circles the drain. Ultimately, it’s a solid 3.5-star choice for a rainy afternoon when you want vibes over high-speed drama.
Julie Olivia’s If It Makes You Happy is a cozy, low-stakes romance that feels like a warm hug for fans of Gilmore Girls and 1997 nostalgia. The autumn atmosphere and Vermont B&B setting are immaculate, providing the perfect backdrop for Cliff, a quintessential "cinnamon roll" single dad who carries the emotional weight of the story. However, the pacing is a true slow burn that occasionally feels more like a crawl, with repetitive banter delaying the romantic payoff until the final act. While the exploration of grief and eldest daughter syndrome is touching, Michelle’s constant internal spiraling and neuroticism can become exhausting for the reader. It is a sweet, comforting read that perfectly captures a specific 90s aesthetic, even if the plot occasionally circles the drain. Ultimately, it’s a solid 3.5-star choice for a rainy afternoon when you want vibes over high-speed drama.
See why thousands of readers are using Bookclubs to stay connected.