Hunter's Heart Ridge: A Mystery (Bethany, Vermont Mysteries Book 2)

By Sarah Stewart Taylor

In this sequel to Taylor’s lyrical series debut, Agony Hill, Detective Frank Warren and his formerly CIA-connected neighbor Alice Bellows return to investigate the death of a diplomat. It's November of 1965 and the second weekend of Vermont's regular deer season when Vermont State Police detective Franklin Warren is called out to what looks like an accidental shooting at The Ridge Club, an exclusive men's hunting and fishing club for congressmen, diplomats, judges, and titans of industry: a former ambassador has been shot while out hunting. With the war in Vietnam picking up speed on the other side of the world, Warren quickly realizes that many of the club’s members are powerful men who may have ulterior motives and connections in high places. While Warren's suspicions about the club members build, his neighbor Alice Bellows is throwing a dinner party, preparing for Thanksgiving, and worrying about her pregnant friend and fellow widow, Sylvie Weber, whose due date is coming up. When Alice's old handler and friend, Arthur Crannock, unexpectedly shows up in Bethany, Alice begins to wonder whether his presence has anything to do with the death at the hunting club. As an early season snowstorm bears down on Bethany, knocking out power and phone lines and blocking the roads, Warren and his assistant, Trooper Pinky Goodrich, are trapped at the Ridge Club, likely along with a killer, and Alice, increasingly fearful that her past in the intelligence world is no longer in the past, will have to act fast to save Sylvie and her baby. Sarah Stewart Taylor’s historical series combines the intricacy of a satisfying mystery with keen observation of a time and place during great transformation and upheaval.

BUY THE BOOK

Published Aug 5, 2025

311 pages

Average rating: 8

1 RATING

|

|

BOOK TALK

Community Reviews

DonneK
8/10 stars
It was nice catching up with VT Statie Frank Warren and the rest of the folks in Bethany, a small town in rural mountains of VT in 1965. The series started out as the Frank Warren series, but now it’s being billed as the Frank Warren and Alice Bellows series. Between the two, I was more interested in Frank Warren and actually found Alice Bellows kind of annoying in the previous installments. Not sure if this is Stewart Taylor’s intention, but there you have it. Over the course of the two full installments and a prequel, there have been numerous references to Alice’s CIA connections. It took two and a half books before Stewart Taylor reveals a quick look into Alice’s past.

Warren on the other hand, seems so much more interesting. A former Boston cop, who left the big city for a small rural State Police position. Widowed and two years later still grieving his wife’s death, Warren starts to become smitten with the very pregnant and widowed Sylvie (from the first installment). Not real convenient since he’s also just started investigating a shooting incident at the local hunting lodge. Warren suspects that the shooting was murder and not accidental like the lodge members claim. However, Warren must proceed carefully with this bunch of influential and DC connected blowhards, or they will have their lawyers lining up to eviscerate him and the VT State PD.

There is also a storyline of Sylvie, who is concerned about her and her baby’s health when she starts to feel like she may not be able to carry to term. Fortunately, Alice has come by to visit and ends up becoming a savior of sorts. Most of the story revolves around the investigation of the death at the lodge with Warren interviewing (several times) the various members of the lodge that were there when the incident happened. After a while, he starts to see holes and inconsistencies in their stories. Then the storm hits fast and hard, throwing the story into a whirlwind of scary and intense activity with some shocks and twists I didn’t see coming.

The character development for most of the primary characters was well done. The pacing was steady for the most part and picking up a bit during the storm and the finale. The storyline is interesting and the writing on par for the series, although this one I enjoyed the most, so far. I’m definitely interested in seeing what Stewart-Taylor does with the next installment. I’m looking at an overall rating of a solid 4star review. I want to thank NetGalley and St Martin’s Press for sending me this eARC in exchange for my honest review.

#NetGalley #StMartinsPress #HuntersHeartRidge